Home Subscribe Services Support Us


Parshas Behalosecha 5759

Outline Vol. 3, # 24

by Rabbi Yaakov Bernstein

One of our readers asked about differences between the Torah's rules for Jewish Courts, as compared to the Torah's rules for Non-Jewish Courts. Since the Beis Din is highly restricted -- in order to further the cause of justice, shouldn't the Non-Jewish Court have the same restrictions?

Before we can deal directly with the question, let's start with some basic concepts.

An incident is recorded In Tractate Baba Metzia. Rabbi Eliezer Hagadol debated with the entire Sanhedrin. When they wouldn't accept his ruling, Rabbi Eliezer Hagadol tried to prove that he was correct by prophetic, supernatural means. Although many signs and wonders were performed, nonetheless, the Rabbis paid no attention. Jewish Law (halacha) is a normative legal system. As such, it cannot be affected by supernatural phenomena. Perhaps the supernatural is valid, perhaps not; the power of the prophet must not be allowed to interfere with the legal process.

Rabbi Yerucham Levovitz brought out another point. Let's accept the idea that the Rabbis were not going to be convinced by the miracles. Even so, it's remarkable that they were not in the least bit impressed. All the wonders had not made any impression upon them whatsoever. Where did Rabbi Eliezer's power come from? What meaning did it have for the Rabbis? Rabbi Yerucham Levovitz referred to an explanation from the Ran: Rabbi Eliezer's miracles were a test for the Rabbis. Would they follow the rulings of the Torah, or not?

Yet another point can be derived from this story. Following the incident, Hashem is reported to have said, "Nitzchu Banai" -- "My children have defeated me!" The implication is that Hashem Himself agreed with Rabbi Eliezer, although the law was decided in accordance with the other opinion! The Rishonim (early authorities) discussed and debated the meaning of these lines.

According to Chinuch, the legal argument of Rabbi Eliezer was more sound, thus Hashem agreed with Rabbi Eliezer's view. However, the vote of the majority of the Sanhedrin is binding, not the soundness of an individual's reasoning. Thus, even though Rabbi Eliezer was, in theory, "correct," nonetheless, the legal process decided otherwise.

Ramban explained in a different manner: The decision of the Sanhedrin, is, by definition, correct. Even if it seems to you that the Sanhedrin has erred, you must humble yourself and try to see things in a different light; they have the authority to decide the laws.

Actually, there may be no real difference between Chinuch and Ramban. Even though Rabbi Eliezer may have had the stronger logic, logic alone does not determine laws. Legally -- by definition -- the Rabbis of the Sanhedrin are indeed "correct."

A recent example of this reasoning occurred during the impeachment trials in the US recently. A friend of the President argued in a speech to the Senate, "The President has not committed an impeachable offense." Commentators pointed out that the statement was incorrect, since the President had already been impeached by those with the authority to impeach!

Our discussion has not addressed the possibility of error; we have simply distinguished between opinion and law. In the next issue, b'ezras Hashem, we will investigate what should occur if the court has apparently erred.


Rabbi Yaakov Bernstein
11 Kiryas Radin
Spring Valley, NY 10977
Phone: (914) 362-5156

Good Shabbos!

Text Copyright © '98 Rabbi Yaakov Bernstein and Project Genesis, Inc.



View Complete List

Concentric Circles:Contrasting Worlds
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5773

Meaning and Purpose: A Good Beginning
Rabbi Label Lam - 5769

From Dust To G-dliness
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5764

> More than One G-d?
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5761

Where are You?
Rabbi Pinchas Avruch - 5762

Getting to Know the Yetzer Hara
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5759

Looking for a Chavrusah?

This Rashi Is Not For the United Nations It is For Us
- 5769

In Light of Creation
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5765

Cherish the Memories
Rabbi Pinchas Avruch - 5764


Let Us Make Man
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5770

Strong Belief
Shlomo Katz - 5759

Opposites Attract
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5760

Frumster - Orthodox Jewish Dating

Genesis and Life
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5765

The Children of Parents
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5756

The Book of Mankind
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5762

No Doubt
Shlomo Katz - 5767

Project Genesis Home

Torah Portion

Jewish Law



Learn the Basics




Ask The Rabbi

Knowledge Base


About Us

Contact Us

Free Book on Geulah! Home Copyright Information