By Richard Greenberg
My friend Yoni (a pseudonym) is a ba'al teshuvah, a newly observant Jew. He
tells this story: He was meeting an old friend in a restaurant, a non-kosher
establishment -- in Texas, no less. (Although Yoni was there to meet, not
Like some Orthodox Jews, Yoni covers his head in public and wears his tzitzis
(ritual fringes) out. He was thus outfitted that day, which may have been a
first for that eatery. As Yoni got up to leave, a restaurant employee eyed
his dangling strings and approached him cautiously, incredulously.
"Excuse me, sir," the attendant whispered and then paused, searching for the
right words. "You have . . . noodles hanging from your pockets."
Welcome to the world of the visible Jew, or in this case, the visibly
religious Jew. It can be a mighty interesting place.
As the name implies, a visibly religious Jew, a VRJ, is one whose garb or
other externals publicly identify him or her not only as a Jew, but as an
observant one. The markers: A kipah. Tzitzis. A fedora, perhaps. Maybe payos.
And for women, covered hair and modest attire, including long skirts rather
"Props perhaps," wrote Baila Olidort in "Wellsprings" magazine, "but they
tell a story more compelling than words."
The stories vary with the wearer, but the underlying philosophical statement
they make does not: Judaism is such an integral part of my life that I am
willing to look different than others as well as act differently.
The VRJ philosophy is in keeping with the time-honored Jewish notion that we
are -- and should continue to be -- not only first-class menschen, but a
distinctive, and sometimes separate, people. ( A chai or a Star of
David worn around the neck sends a similar message. However, those articles are not included here because they are
not necessarily indicators of *religious* commitment).
The process of becoming a VRJ can be slow and fitful for the same reasons
that it is meaningful. That is, it takes courage and commitment to buck
secular social norms and publicly broadcast one's religious worldview.
It took me a while, for example, to clear the "kipah barrier," that
succession of psychological hurdles that confronts some men who are in the
process of publicly declaring their Jewishness for the first time.
To visualize the "kipah barrier," think of a series of concentric circles,
each succeeding one delineating a new and expanded zone of comfort in which
someone is willing to be seen wearing his head covering. Travel in these
precincts, however, can be painstakingly slow due to self-consciousness on
the part of the newcomer -- even in a putatively religious community.
The first zone of comfort, typically, might encompass one's property. The
next zone: The rest of the block, followed by the entire neighborhood.
Eventually, the mall, the subway and beyond. At each step, though, the
background question lingers: If I bump into so-and-so from a previous life,
how will I explain my new "look" without sounding weird?
The workplace is often the final frontier (although wearing a kipah there is
not necessarily a halachic [Jewish Law] imperative). Many assimilated Jews who rediscover their religious roots recall having reached the
point where they felt comfortable wearing a kipah almost anywhere --
certainly wherever they were among other religious Jews or, alternatively, in
settings where they enjoyed anonymity.
But the workplace -- among non-religious and non-Jewish colleagues who had
long known them in an entirely secular context -- was a different story. Too
much baggage. Too many questions. Too many opportunities for embarrassment.
As a result, they'd typically commute to work wearing a kipah, but furtively
remove it just before entering the office -- and repeat the process in
reverse after work. In one case, though, the newly observant Jew told me he
was shamed into leaving his kipah on, not by a Jew, but by a gentile
colleague who confronted him when he saw him remove his kipah in the company
"You should be ashamed of youself," the gentile told him, and lectured him on
the importance of taking pride in one's identity and celebrating that fact,
regardless of where he happens to find himself.
"So I thought about it for 48 hours," the Jew said, "and got the courage to
put a kipah on my head and keep it on while I was in the office. For about 24
hours, people would come by [and ask] was it a holiday or what? And I dealt
with the questions, and that was it."
In that respect, his experience apparently was not atypical. Most of the
kipah-wearers I spoke with said the initial workplace "curiosity storm"
lasted no more a few days to a week.
Being a VRJ is not only a declaration of religious identity, a membership
card in the club of believers. It is also an invitation for others to view us
through whatever prism they define as "Jewish."
The reaction from fellow Jews (non-VRJs) runs the gamut, although some seem
to assume that the VRJ (if male) is a rabbi. Why else would a Jew walk around
that way in public?
Yet some of the same Jews seem drawn to us, perhaps because we're a visible
link to something they value, a remembrance. Sometimes, I think, we give them
an opportunity to declare their own Jewishness.
In the supermarket, for example, I've repeatedly had people who don't appear
to be Jewish wish me a good yontif or go out of their way to say something in
Yiddish or Hebrew or make some other Jewish reference. They didn't know me
from Avraham; but they did know I was a Jew. And they wanted it known that
they were, too. A connection was formed -- however fleeting -- and it
wouldn't have happened if not for my visibility. At times like that, being a
VRJ is a public service.
Meanwhile, my interaction with non-Jews has been overwhelmingly positive,
precisely I think, because I am a VRJ. I've heard this from other VRJs, too.
I think many Gentiles respect someone who is willing to go public with his or
That's one of the perks of being a VRJ. But it comes with strings attached,
and I don't mean tzitzis. A visible Jew is a de facto ambassador for an
entire religion, and as a result, has a responsibility to maintain especially
high ethical and moral standards. When the spotlight is shining on your
kipah, it's a potent reminder to behave properly and treat others with
respect and kindness -- whether they're panhandlers or businesspeople.
Not long after I became a VRJ, a gentile merchant mistakenly undercharged me
for a major appliance purchase. In my pre-VRJ days, I'm not sure exactly what
I would have done. In this case, however, I corrected the error on the spot
-- not only because it was the right thing to do, but because I knew that the
merchant knew that a Jew (me) was on the other side of the counter. In my
mind, I was representing all Jews when I told him to double check his
figures. When he was finished with his math, he looked up from his
calculator, smiled sheepishly and thanked me graciously. Any doubts I might
still have had about being a visibly religious Jew evaporated pretty quickly
Richard Greenberg, a Washington area writer, is the author of the book
"Pathways: Jews Who Return," published by Jason Aronson Inc. "Pathways" is a
collection of stories told by once-assimilated Jews who have come to
reconnect with their spiritual roots. Mr. Greenberg is available to discuss
his book and related matters at 301-649-0846 or Rickg613@aol.com.
|I don't know how long this article has been up, but I just stumbled upon it and I am compelled to say that I found the last paragraph very refreshing. While I am by no means a "VRJ," I always felt that it was up to every member of a given race, religion, or creed to make themselves the best denouncers of myths and stereotypes as a service to the rest of their people. Making a point to show that Jews are not cheap people out to steal money was very noble, and I applaud you. I cannot honestly say that I would make the same decision on the spot, although I would likely feel guilty about it later. I'm reminded of an incident from about 7 years ago. When I was much younger (roughly 13 years or so, I'm 22), I stole an eraser from my school bookstore. The line was long (the first day of school; everyone was buying many books). Since I only had an eraser, I got fed up waiting and I left, eraser in hand. I promptly forgot about it, and it was not until I started examining myself and who I was (around the time of my Bar Mitzvah) that I remembered the "incident" and returned to the store to pay for what I had taken. It turns out that in the intervening years I had developed a rapport with the keeper of the store, and I felt I owed it to both of us to admit to it and pay back the cost, even though it was only 25 cents. |
|* * * * *|
Fruits of Passion
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5772
Our Relevance to the Infinite
Rabbi Yosef Kalatzky - 5762
Bilam's Big Appetite
Shlomo Katz - 5760
Die Like a Jew
Rabbi Raymond Beyda - 5767
Three Differences Between Bilaam and Rabbi Yosi ben Kisma
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5771
Building With Failure
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5760
A Great Responsibility
Shlomo Katz - 5768
Pray for the 'Right' Person
Shlomo Katz - 5758
Rabbi Chaim Flom - 5767
Is Sincerity at Steak?
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5761
From Amidst The Ashes
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5764
Mistaking The Angel of Mercy For The Satan
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5770
All Day Long
Rabbi Label Lam - 5767
Money Order - Getting Our Priorities Straight
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5764
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5772
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5762