Rabbi Avi Shafran
Along with oppressive heat, maddening insects, and sticky shirts, New York
summers can be counted on to provide another seasonal annoyance: Jews for
The brightly-T-shirted pushers of the group's literature -- which lately
seems to consist of cartoonish briefs about Christian salvation -- are
stationed at a variety of subway stations, ferry terminals and
pedestrian-heavy corners. All smiles and proffered pamphlets, they accost
every passer-by. When they see me, with my unfashionable beard and black
hat -- a rather obvious Orthodox Jew -- some shrink imperceptibly
(fearing, presumably, that I might be rabid and in a biting mood), but
most smile even harder and thrust their wares forward with even greater
enthusiasm. Even the remote hope of converting so Jewish-looking a Jew
must fill their heads with visions of a bright Hereafter.
Sometimes I stop and ask "Are you Jewish?" Most, interestingly, are not.
When I get the rare affirmation, I trade my business card for the pamphlet,
and offer to speak with the young person by phone at a more convenient time
"if you're really interested in understanding Judaism."
Usually they aren't. And on the rare occasion when they actually call,
they seem programmed to just mouth lines they've rehearsed. One gets the
feeling they aren't listening, or for some reason cannot hear.
That is particularly ironic in light of the group's most recent
advertising campaign just across the pond. A billboard ad it is running
in Britain features a group of religious Orthodox Jews dressed, as
religious Orthodox Jews are wont to dress, in white shirts and dark
outergarments. One of the men, however, is wearing a bright red Jews for
Jesus T-shirt, while a slogan urges the viewer to "Think for Yourself."
The ad is clever. It plays into preconceptions -- all too common not only
in the non-Jewish world but, sadly, the Jewish one as well -- about
traditional Judaism being monotonous and unquestioning.
In reality, though, few identifiable religious communities are as vibrant
and variegated as the traditional Jews of our day; while Jewish Law binds
all its adherents together by the most important thing in their lives --
the Torah -- the Jewish mosaic is comprised of many very different groups,
and reflects a broad assortment of approaches and attitudes. Major issues
running the gamut from the role of secular education in Jewish life to the
place of Zionism in Jewish history -- not to mention a host of more
mundane matters -- are perennial subjects of vigorous disagreement among
traditionally observant Jews. If there's anything that religious Jews tend
to do with a vengeance (so to speak), it's think for themselves.
And they are among the most Jewishly knowledgeable as well, which may well
be part of why Jews for Jesus chose to ridicule them. The group, after all,
feeds off Jewish ignorance.
The overwhelming majority of missionary-snatched souls belonged to Jews
woefully uneducated about their own religious heritage. Many, by their
own published accounts, received little or no Jewish education, and even
less in the way of Jewish life at home. That is why "Messianic"
congregations have such success with Jews from the former Soviet Union,
whose upbringings were devoid of true Jewish content. Jews with even a
modicum of Jewish knowledge recognize the insinuation that a Jew is
"unfulfilled" unless he adds Christianity to his beliefs as absurd.
And so, what better means for missionary Jew-targeters to try to ensure an
abundance of ripe marks than to mock those very Jews whose example -- by
their dedication to the learning and living of Judaism -- undermines their
So stupid they're not. But the spectacle of a group dedicated to
exploiting ignorance, peddling absurdities and portraying knowledgeable,
observant Jews as dullards carries the word "chutzpah" to new lows.
It might inspire us all, though, to summon a little chutzpah of our own, and
dare to learn something useful from Jews for Jesus' choice. For the group,
it is clear, is mocking what it most fears, and we would do well to ponder
that well-placed apprehension.
Because the antidote for ignorance is knowledge, and the cure for Jewish
malaise is Jewish learning and living. We can argue with missionaries until
our faces are blue, and we can protest the misrepresentation of Jewish
sources and practices until the (Jewish) Messiah arrives.
But the most efficient and meaningful way to counter those who view Jews as
spiritual prey is to foster more of what the soul-hunters most dread, what
they know will spell their defeat: Jewish knowledge.
[Rabbi Avi Shafran is director of public affairs for Agudath Israel of
AM ECHAD RESOURCES
|I'm not Jewish, but as a great respecter of the Jewish faith, I heartily applaud this article, which is well written, well thought out, and stunning in its logic. There is something so intrinsically artificial and cheap about this group; it's good to see it observed and put in its place from within the very heart of Judaism. Well done. |
- M. R. -0/4-/2005
|* * * * *|
|Well stated. I understand it to be a sin for a Jew to recruit non-Jews. In Chritianity, recruitment is a 'mitzvah'. My concern is deceptive recruitment which I always ask those who engage in the deceit mode to recruit is "Would Jesus approve of deceptive tactics to get his message across?. When a J. Witness knocks on my door, there is no deceit. They have always been up-front in their intent and I only have to say "thank you and no thank you. I am happy and secure where I am as a Jew." They have never poshed beyond that; no deceit. JFJ is total deception basded simply on the basis that if you accept Jesus as your Messiah, you are not a Jew. |
- R. B. -0/9-/2003
|* * * * *|
|When I was in college, a student asked me about Jews for Jesus because he didn't understand it. He thought it was contradictory, which it is. The odd part is that this student wasn't Jewish, and yet he thought it was a contradiction. When I have tried to explain the problem with Jews for Jesus to Gentiles, they don't understand. The usual reply is that it's a religious belief. They don't understand that Jews for Jesus is like Catholics for Muhammad. Jews usually understand that Jews for Jesus is bogus, but many Gentiles have a much harder time. |
|* * * * *|
|While I fully applaud all efforts in the orthodox community to combat the plague of Jews for Jesus and other messianic [sic] Jewish sects, I am dismayed and disquieted by the absense of non-orthodox Jews in the anti-missionary movement. While it is true that the percentage of non-orthodox Jews with a solid Jewish education is smaller than that among orthodx Jews, the fact is that educated conservative and even reform Jews can be effective in the war against this 'Christian crusade with a Jewish veneer.'
In this battle, we Jews are all in it together. |
- M. K. -0/9-/2003
|* * * * *|
|Chutzpah indeed! And a little I suspect on your part as well. OK by me. What they all do in the name of religion is really amazing, and their continued recitation of their mantra against the very basis upon which they "claim" to base their ideology is shocking, at the very least. I have provided insight to some of them, and at least caused them to question their belief system. But I must state that in no way should Yisrael condone or allow such activity to continue. I flies in the very face of TORAH. |
- E. B. -0/9-/2003
|* * * * *|
|View More Comments|
Mixed Multitude of Troubles
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5760
Conspiracies and Lost Opportunities
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5758
A Purifying Proccess
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5762
All Pain, No Gain
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5760
Bilaam: A Hard Act to Swallow
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5757
Window of Opportunity
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5766
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5757
Listen To The Mocking Bird
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5756
Living Through Death
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5762
From Amidst The Ashes
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5764
Money Order - Getting Our Priorities Straight
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5764
Victory is With-in-Reach
Rabbi Label Lam - 5772
Tents Where Torah is Studied
Shlomo Katz - 5767
Was G-d Bilaam's Agent?
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5761
Rabbi Raymond Beyda - 5763
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5768