1. G’d the Source of Life
The Torah tells us that the Altar upon which the burnt offerings were
brought was made of wood and was covered with a thin layer of copper. It is
therefore referred to as “the copper Altar” and “the Altar of burnt
offerings.” The Midrash states, “Moshe said before G’d, ‘Master of the
Universe, You had commanded me to make an Altar from Achacia wood and cover
it with copper. You also told me that there will be a continuous fire that
burns upon it. Will the fire not melt away the copper and burn the wood that
is beneath it?’ G’d responded to Moshe, ‘The fact that fire burns through
copper and consumes wood is a phenomenon that exists within the physical
realm. However, in the spiritual realm these laws do not apply. Gaze upon
the angels. They are composed of a consuming fire. In addition, in the
spiritual realm there are great amounts of ice, yet the fire of the angels
does not melt it. Fire and ice coexist without interfering with one another.”
The Midrash continues, “You (Moshe) have witnessed things that were not
alive and suddenly became alive. As you had seen regarding the staff of
Aaron. It was a staff made from dry wood; however, when there was a question
about who was qualified to be the High Priest, he was told to put his staff
among the staffs of the other Princes of the other Tribes. Aaron’s staff
sprouted almonds while the others remained non-fruit bearing. When something
comes in contact with the Divine Presence, life is infused into it. Reb Levy
explains that when King Solomon brought the Holy Ark into the Temple, all
the wood in the Temple became moist. The Cedar wood began to sprout fruits.
As it states, ‘That which was planted in the courtyard of G’d began to
sprout (fruits.)’ It was from these fruits that the Priests were sustained.
However, when King Menasha, brought idolatry into the Temple, the viability
of the wood was lost. It once again returned to its dry state and no longer
produced fruit.” Therefore, Moshe did not need to be concerned that the
fire that burned continuously upon the Altar would melt away the copper
covering and burn the wood. Because setting of the Altar was part of the
spiritual realm it was not subject to the laws of nature. Was this fact not
known to Moshe? What was the basis for Moshe’s lack of understanding that
required G’d’s response?
The Midrash tells us that at Sinai every Jew was restored to a physical
state of perfection. Whoever had been previously blind was able to see. If
one were crippled, he was able to stand. Those who were deaf were able to
hear. This is because the Divine Presence had come upon Sinai. Since G’d is
the source of all life and existence, anything that is within His proximity
is infused with a life force and thus assumes a state of perfection. There
is no deficiency within the life force that one receives directly from G’d.
Anything that is exposed to His Presence assumes a perfected state.
However, after the sin of the Golden Calf G’d distanced himself from the
Jewish people. Those who had been previously handicapped to revert back to
their imperfect state.
Moshe had understood that the Mishkan had a semblance of Sinai but was not
an exact replication. Since the Jewish people themselves were no longer
qualified to contain the Divine Presence, within their midst, it was only
through the medium of the Mishkan that they were able to have a relationship
with G’d. Moshe believed that the Mishkan was no longer a representation of
the spiritual realm. It was therefore subject to physical phenomena. The
continuous fire on the alter would ultimately destroy it.
Ramban explains that every aspect of the Mishkan reflected and symbolized
the setting of Sinai. Thus, the Mishkan was a replication of Sinai to
accommodate G’d’s Presence. Moshe, therefore needed to be informed that
despite the spiritual regression of the Jewish people, as a result of the
sin of the Golden Calf, the Mishkan itself was not diminished regarding its
Chazal tell us that before Adam had sinned by eating from the Tree of
Knowledge all trees were fruit bearing. It was only after the sin that
non-fruit bearing trees came into being. After the sin of Adam, the world
became tainted and thus G’d distanced Himself from the physicality of
existence. Consequently, some trees no longer bore fruit because they were
no longer attached to the source of life. They existed in a deficient state.
At the end of time, when G’d will return and permeate all existence with
his presence, all trees will once again produce fruit.
The Torah tells us that Moshe had said to the Jewish people, “For forty days
and forty nights bread I did not eat and water I did not drink.” When Moshe
was in heaven receiving the Torah on behalf of the Jewish people, he existed
without food or drink. How is it possible for a physical being to survive
without physical sustenance for such an extended period of time? Because
Moshe had ascended to the spiritual realm and was in the proximity of the
Divine Presence, he no longer had any physical needs. He was sustained by
the source of everything, which is G’d Himself. It is only when one is
distant from the Divine Source does one return to ones natural state.
G’d explained to Moshe that although the Jewish people had regressed because
of the sin of the Golden Calf, the Mishkan itself retained the status of
Sinai. It was functional within the spiritual realm. Therefore, the
continuous fire on the Altar would not wear away the copper covering and
consume the Altar.
2. The Jew’s Presence in Existence
The Torah tells us that G’d commanded the Jewish people to build the Mishkan
saying, “Make for Me a dwelling place so that I may dwell in your midst...”
Chazal tell us that the sequential reading of the Torah is not always in
chronological order. When was the commandment to build the Mishkan given?
Did it precede the sin of the Golden Calf or was it only after the Jewish
people had sinned that they were they given this mitzvah? Based on the
sequential reading of the Torah, the mitzvah of building the Mishkan was
given before the sin of the Golden Calf.
The Midrash tells us that the commandment for the building of the Mishkan
was communicated to Moshe on Yom Kippur. The first Yom Kippur occurred
after the Jewish people had sinned with the Golden Calf. Because Moshe had
smashed the first set of Tablets when seeing the Golden Calf being
worshiped, the Jewish people needed their relationship with G’d reinstated
through a second set of Tablets. The second set of Tablets was a
confirmation to the Jewish people that they were forgiven for the sin of the
Golden Calf. This took place on Yom Kippur. At this time Moshe was told by
G’d to tell the Jewish people to build the Mishkan.
The Midrash states, “Although the Portion of the building of the Mishkan
appears before the sin of the Golden Calf the mitzvah was actually given
after the sin…On Yom Kippur G’d commanded Moshe, ‘Make for Me a Sanctuary….’
Why was this mitzvah given on Yom Kippur? It was so that the nations of the
world should know that G’d had forgiven His people for the sin of the Golden
Calf. This is the reason the Mishkan is referred to as ‘the Mishkan of the
Testament.’ It is a testament to the nations of the world that G’d had
forgiven the Jewish people for the Golden Calf, since G’d’s Presence dwelt
in their midst. G’d had said, ‘Let the gold that was given for the building
of the Mishkan atone for the gold of the Calf.’” Why was it important for
the nations of the world to know that the Jewish people were forgiven for
the sin of the Golden Calf?
After the splitting of the Sea, the world stood in awe of the Jewish people
because G’d had altered nature on the most miraculous level to destroy the
mightiest and most advanced civilization on their behalf. This did not
deter the Amalekites from attacking them. Although the world at large was
overwhelmed with awe and thus would not dare approach the Jewish people, the
Amalekites attacked them without any regard. The Midrash explains that the
Amalekite attack on the Jewish people is analogous to a fool jumping into a
scolding hot bath that others are frightened to go near for fear of being
burned. However the fool, who jumps into the bath, although he is scolded,
he nevertheless cools down the bath for others to enter. Before the Jewish
people were attacked by the Amalekites, they were revered and esteemed by
the nations of the world. The attack of the Amalekites undermined that
special reverence and awe that the world had for them. Consequently, the
level of influence that the Jewish people could have had on the world was no
longer the same because they were seen after the attack as being no
different than any other nation. The Jewish people were meant to be the
inspiration and motivation through which the world would revere G’d and
become monotheistic. However, after being attacked, since their aura was
diminished this no longer would take place. G’d therefore said, “My Throne
will not be complete until Amalek is obliterated from under the heaven.”
Amalek had brought about the ultimate desecration of G’d.
If the mitzvah of building the Mishkan is believed to have been given before
the sin of the Golden Calf, then it would be possible for the nations of the
world to claim that the Jewish people were disenfranchised from being the
chosen people as a result of their spiritual failing. They had forfeited
their divine status. G’d, therefore, G’d gave the commandment to build the
Mishkan on the first Yom Kippur after the sin of the Golden Calf to inform
the world that the Jewish people were in fact forgiven and reinstated as His
holy people. They thus were able to continue and function within existence
as before the sin of the Golden Calf. They were the model for the world to
see how to worship G’d and live by His Word. The mission of the Jewish
people is to be the testament to the world that G’d is the Creator. Without
reinstatement, this representation of G’dliness would no longer be viable.
The Midrash tells us that the Greek exile is alluded in the words of the
Torah regarding creation “darkness (choshech).” This is because the Greeks
had “Blackened the eyes of the Jewish people through their harsh decrees.”
The Greeks decreed that every Jew should engrave on the horn of a cow, “We
have no share in the G’d of Israel.” This horn was to be displayed in the
household of every Jew. Maharal of Prague explains that the reason the
Greeks chose the horn of a cow was to allude to the sin of the Golden Calf.
They wanted to diminish and discredit the Jewish people, who believed that
they had a special relationship with G’d because of the Sinai event. The
Greeks had said, “If a woman were to have an adulterous affair after many
years of marriage, it would not necessarily reflect upon the original
relationship between the husband and wife. Initially they were fully
committed to one another. However, if the adulterous affair were to take
place immediately after the wedding, then it is obvious that there was never
a relationship between husband and wife.” This is what the Greeks had said
to the Jewish people. How is it possible that the initial commitment of the
Jewish people to G’d had any value if soon after being taken as His people
they engaged in idolatry. Therefore, the Greeks wanted the Jewish people
themselves to acknowledge the fact, through the inscription on the horn of
the cow, that there was never a relationship between themselves and G’d.
They should not delude themselves with such foolishness. This is the meaning
of “they wanted to darken the eyes of the Jewish people.” They did not want
them to believe that they were the chosen people of G’d.
The Jew is meant to represent G’d in this existence through his being and
thus would be a light unto the world. However, the Greeks attempted to
extinguish that light. Thus “They blackened the eyes of the Jewish people…”
The Greeks wanted to minimize the Jewish people in their own eyes and in the
eyes of the world so that they could no longer influence existence with
holiness. Therefore, G’d gave the mitzvah of the building of the Mishkan on
Yom Kippur to demonstrate to the world that they were fully forgiven and
reinstated, despite the sin of the Golden Calf.
3. The Positive Side of Disappointment
The Torah states, “Now you shall command the Children of Israel that they
shall take for you pure, pressed olive oil for illumination, to kindle the
lamp continuously…” The Mitzvah of kindling the Menorah was incumbent on
Aaron and his children, the Priests. The Gemara in Tractate Bava Basra
explains that the light of the Menorah symbolizes the Oral Law, which is an
elucidation of the Written Law. Through the kindling of the Menorah, the
Jewish people merit the Divine Assistance that is necessary for one to
fathom G’d’s Wisdom.
The Midrash states, “You (G’d) illuminate all creation, yet You command us
to kindle the lights of the Menorah. Reb Meir says, 'G'd said, 'The lights
that Aaron kindles are more beloved to Me then the luminaries that I have
set in the heavens.' Why is this so? When all of the Princes had brought
gifts and sacrifices on behalf of the inauguration of the Mishkan, the Tribe
of Levy was not included. As a result, Aaron was personally pained and was
in a state of melancholy. He had said, ‘All of the Princes were asked to
participate in the inauguration of the Mishkan, but I have no share in the
offerings. ‘ G'd responded to him, ‘I swear, that while their participation
was only one time, you will have your own special inauguration by kindling
the lights of Menorah.' … This is what is meant by the verse in Psalms, ‘The
desires of the humble, G’d had heard.’” Aaron’s kindling of the Menorah was
more beloved to G’d than all of the luminaries in heaven because its
kindling was G’d’s response to Aaron’s pain of being excluded. His pain was
a demonstration of his dedication and love for G’d. His pain did not emanate
from the fact that he was denied personal glory, but rather, he was pained
that he did not participate in the sanctification of G’d’s Name.
We find something similar, regarding the hospitality of Avraham. The Torah
tells us that on the third day after Avraham's circumcision, which is the
most difficult day of recovery,” he was sitting at the entrance of his tent
in the heat of the day”. Chazal explain that from the beginning of existence
until that moment there was no hotter day. G'd had taken the sun out of its
sheath in order to discourage wayfarers from coming to Avraham so that he
should be able to recuperate. Despite G'd's attempt to create a setting of
respite for Avraham, he was disturbed and pained that he could not offer his
hospitality to people for the sake of espousing monotheism. In order to
alleviate Avraham’s pain, G’d sent three angels in the form of men for him
to host. The Torah describes in detail every aspect of hospitality that
Avraham had provided for the angels. It describes how he had offered the
shade of his tree and water to wash their feet. He offered them bread and
slaughtered calves on their behalf. The Gemara in Tractate Bava Metzia tells
us that for every aspect of his hospitality, his children were paid in kind.
In the merit of the shade of his tree the Jewish people merited the Clouds
of Glory in the desert. In the merit of the bread, they merited the Manna.
In the merit of the water that he provided the angels, they merited the
living well-spring that travelled with them throughout their forty-year trek
in the desert.
The hospitality that Avraham had offered himself, G’d provided for the
Jewish people without any human initiative. What was offered through an
intermediary, required Moshe’s participation to bring it about through a
miracle, such as striking the rock. Avraham, at the time of the circumcision
was already 99 years old. He had provided hospitality for wayfarers and
performed acts of kindness for many years. Why does the Torah single-out
this particular moment of hospitality? Why does it choose to scrutinize and
evaluate its merit to a greater degree than all previous acts of kindness?
It was only because Avraham was pained by the fact that he was denied the
opportunity to serve G’d that his act of hosting the angels was valued to a
greater degree. If one is denied the performance of a mitzvah and
experiences a sense of loss and pain, and subsequently is able to perform
the mitzvah, that act will assume a greater dimension of spiritual value.
4. The Inner Workings of Existence
The Torah states regarding the placement of the Menorah, “In the Tent of the
Meeting, outside the Curtain that is near the Testimonial (Ark)." The
Menorah was located on the outer side of the Curtain, that separates between
the Holy and the Holy of Holies.
The Midrash states, “The Menorah should be kindled outside of the Curtain so
that you should not think, ‘I (G’d) need your light.’” G’d does not need
anything, because His perfection is absolute. The purpose of the Torah and
mitzvos that are performed by the Jewish people to serve G’d are only, so
that they should be the beneficiaries of His Goodness. The Gemara in
Tractate Bava Basra tells us that the light of the Menorah symbolizes the
Oral Law, which is G’d’s elucidation of His Written Word. The logical
location for the Menorah to be place should have been along side the Holy
Ark, which is the repository of the Tablets and the written Torah. However,
the location of the Menorah was in the area of the Holy, not along side the
ark so that one should not mistakenly believe the G’d needs our light.
The Midrash continues, “Moshe said to G’d, ‘You are the light of the world.
Why then do You command us to kindle the lights of the Menorah?’ G’d
responded, ‘To elevate you in the eyes of the nations of the world. So that
they should see that G’d needs your light." Seemingly the two statements of
the Midrash are contradictory. If in fact G’d does not need the light of the
Jewish people, then what is the meaning of the second Midrash that G’d does
need the light of the Jew?
Regarding G’d Himself, He is not in need of anything because need indicates
deficiency. He is not deficient to any degree. Every mitzvah that the Jew
performs is to attain his own spiritual perfection. It will cause him to
become worthy of having a relationship with G’d. One of the tenets of
Judaism is that there is a system of reward and punishment that is in
effect. If one adheres to the dictates of the Torah he will be rewarding
however if one transgressed his word one is held culpable. Since the
objective of Creation was for the sake of the Jewish people to achieve
perfection through the Torah, the function of physical existence thus
affected by their spiritual achievements and failures. All the blessing
that comes to existence is based on the spiritual performance of the Jewish
people. When they live and abide by the principles and dictates of the
Torah, the world is elevated and receives G’d’s bounty. The Jew is the one
who is the determining factor of whether the world rises or falls. This is
the meaning of the Midrash that states, “I need your light.” However, G’d
is not bound by any laws, ordinances, or systems that were put in place. He
may choose to override them whenever He sees fit. Pharaoh and the Egyptians
mistakenly believed that G’d was bound by the Zodiac and the natural order.
Even when the Jewish people are not worthy of receiving His Kindness, G’d
may choose to allow them to be beneficiaries of His blessing. This is an
expression of His dominion. We say at the end of the first blessing of the
Amidah, (Silent Prayer), “…Who recalls the kindnesses of the Patriarchs and
brings the Redeemer to their children’s children for the sake of His Name,
with love.” The Jewish people are maintained in existence because of the
merits of the Patriarchs. However, when those merits are depleted, G’d will
bring the Redeemer (Moshiach) for the sake of His Name with love. Despite
the fact that the Jewish people may have exhausted the merits of the
Patriarchs and are unworthy of redemption, G’d will nevertheless bring
Moshiach. The reason Moshiach has not yet come is because the world is
still maintained by their merit. It is preferable that the existence should
advance and perfect itself due to the free choice of the Jew. However, when
the merit of the Patriarchs will no longer be G’d will choose to do as He
Rambam writes in the last of the thirteen tenets of Jewish belief, “O
believe with complete faith that there will be a resuscitation of the dead
whenever the wish emanates from the Creator…” Meaning, G’d will decide and
determine when the resurrection of the dead will occur. This determination
will be made outside of the constraints of any system, calculations, or
order. It is solely based when He deems it fit to do so.
It is interesting to note that the Torah states regarding the materials that
were given to build the Mishkan, “Take for Me Terumah…” One would think
that it should have stated, “Give for Me Terumah…”. The reason the Torah
uses the term “take” rather than “give” is to indicate that when one gives
in accordance with the Will of G’d one is in fact “taking” because he is the
beneficiary of his own actions. G’d does not in any way need or benefit from
the service of the Jewish people, but rather they are the beneficiaries.
5. Torah, the Mechanism For Spiritualization
The Torah states, “(G’d said to Moshe) Now you shall command the Children
of Israel that they shall take for you pure, pressed/crushed olive oil for
illumination (Menorah)…” It seems from the words“…that they shall take for
you (Moshe)…” that the Jewish people were to take, for the sake of Moshe,
the first droplet of pure olive oil for the illumination of the Menorah.
Why were they commanded to do this for the sake of Moshe?
Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh cites the Zohar that states the Jewish people were
redeemed from the first three of their four exiles in the merit of the
Patriarchs. In the merit of Avraham, our Patriarch, they were redeemed from
the Babylonian exile. In the merit of Yitzchak, our Patriarch, they were
redeemed from the Persian exile. In the merit of Yaakov, our Patriarch, they
were redeemed from the Greek exile. The redemption of the Jewish people from
the fourth and current exile, the Edomite exile (Roman), will come about
only in the merit of Moshe. However, Moshe, being the personification of
Torah, will not allow his merit to be utilized to bring about redemption
until the Jewish people are quantitatively and qualitatively engaged in
Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh explains that the “pure, pressed olive oil” of the
Menorah symbolizes the manner in which one must engage in Torah study in
order to be worthy of Moshe’s merit. Just as only the purest droplet of oil
qualifies to kindle the Menorah, so too must one study Torah with a pure
intent. The Torah must be studied for its own sake (l’shmah). Just as the
olive was crushed in order to extract the pure oil for illumination, so too
must one be willing to sacrifice and deprive himself from the material for
the sake of Torah study. It is only when the Jewish people will engage in
Torah in this manner, will Moshe allow his merit to be used to bring about
We pray every day in the blessing for the Davidic Reign (es tzemach David
avdecha) in the Amidah (Silent Prayer) that G’d should bring the Moshiach,
speedily in our day. The Gemara tells us that when Moshiach will come, G’d
obviousness will be so evident that one will no longer have free choice. The
primary focus of humanity will be to address and advance their spirituality.
Rambam writes in the Laws of Repentance that one’s deservingness of reward
is based on one’s ability to choose between right and wrong. However, if
one is no longer in conflict because he is compelled to do good because of
its obviousness, then one is no longer deserving of reward. If the coming of
Moshiach will bring an end to the setting of free choice, which is the
ultimate objective of creation, then why do we pray for his coming?
We pray for the coming of Moshiach because when G’d’s Presence is not
experienced and felt, it becomes a setting for a desecration of His Name. We
are willing to forego and deny ourselves for His sake, the purpose of our
own existence, which is spiritual advancement. Why would Moshe, who had
dedicated his life selflessly to G’d’s Glory, deny the Jewish people their
final redemption to bring about the greatest glorification of G’d?
Moshe understood that without proper Torah study, one would not have the
capacity to internalize and appreciate the ultimate revelation of G’d’s
Presence. The only way one would be qualified and be sufficiently developed
to understand its value, one must engage in Torah study in a qualitative and
selfless manner. Only then will His revelation be understood. Not
appreciating G’d’s Presence, when it is most obvious, would be the ultimate
desecration. Therefore, Moshe chooses to withhold his merit from the Jewish
people to prevent a greater desecration of G’d’s Name.
Text Copyright © 2012 by Rabbi Yosef Kalatsky and Torah.org.
Rabbi Kalatsky is the founder of the Yad Avraham Institute, a New York-based learning center whose mission is to disseminate Torah to Jews of all backgrounds and walks of life.