In this week's portion, the Torah tells us to decimate any remnant of
idolatry: "You shall utterly destroy all the places where the nations that
you are driving away worshiped their gods - on the high mountains and on
the hills, and under every leafy tree. You shall break apart their altars,
you shall smash their pillars, and their sacred trees shall you burn in the
fire. Their carved images shall you cut down, and you shall obliterate
their names from that place." (Deuteronomy 12:2-3)
But then, the Torah adds a verse that seems to be so unnecessary, if not
wounding. The Torah tells us "You shall not do the same to Hashem, your
The Talmud explains that from this verse we derive a prohibition against
destroying synagogue property and erasing the name of Hashem. Rashi,
however, quotes the Sifri, which offers an amazing interpretation: R
Ishmael asks, "Can even a thought enter in your mind that the Jewish nation
would break the altars of Hashem?"
Thus Rabbi Yishmael gives an homiletic interpretation of the verse. He says
that the verse is not necessarily an admonition against physically breaking
the walls of the Sanctuary, but rather it is a warning to the nation not to
sin, thereby causing the Sanctuary of (built by) your fathers to be destroyed.
Rav Moshe Feinstein points out an amazing anomaly. Rabbi Yishmael is
bothered at the simple connotation of the verse that he does not interpret
it at face value. He can hardly fathom that there are Jews who need to be
told not to break stones in the Altar, or the Temple. Therefore, he
expounds that this refers to Jews who sin, and cause the destruction of the
Temple. Yet when the Torah warns about idolatry, adultery, or murder, Rabbi
Yishmael is mute. He does not ask, "Is it possible that a Jew would murder
or commit idolatry? He is not shocked at the need to warn against adultery.
He does not reinterpret those verses homiletically and explain them in a
poetic fashion. He is quite content with the admonition in its purest and
most simple form. Though he can accept Jews committing murder, but he
cannot accept them smashing synagogues. What is the difference?
(Recently I heard this amazing story. However, I have changed the names of
the parties involved and the location.)
Velvel was infamous in his native Tarnogrod. A notorious gangster, he not
only transgressed the mitzvos, but mocked those who observed them. He
really did not have much to do with the members of the community, if not to
lure someone into a promising business deal, only to rob him of his
Velvel rarely visited the inside of the shul, save every few years on the
yahrzeit of his pious father when the cobwebs of time were dusted off by
the winds of guilt. Yes, Velvel was different than most of the villagers.
Except for early 1940, when he was no different than anyone else. The Nazis
had overrun the town. They herded the community into the shul, and unfurled
the Torah scrolls on the floor. Then they lined the people up and told them
to march on the Torah, forcing them to spit on it as they past. And Velvel
was right there amongst them. Velvel was a Jew and no different from anyone
Everyone lined up t o obey and Velvel pushed to be first on line. And then
he showed how special, how different he was. As he approached the Torah he
stopped short, not even letting the tips of his soles touch the sacred
parchment. Then he turned to the SS officer. "I don't tread on my Torah and
I will never spit on it." They shot him on the spot, and like the rest of
the villagers who followed suit, Velvel became a holy martyr.
Rav Feinstein explains that there are icons of Judaism that are virtually
impregnable. And so, Rabbi Yishmael can understand that one can be
completely detached from Judaism, to the extent that he disregards all the
mitzvos, and transgresses the most awful of it's prohibitions. However,
that Jew, no matter how low he has sunk, will never destroy even one brick
of a synagogue! That is why Rabbi Yishmael must explain the verse not
through its simple meaning, but through a pastoral interpretation.
The love of Judaism transcends performance of any single command. And no
Jew who heeds some Torah warning, needs admonition against destroying all
that his soul embodies. In this era of shattered icons and crumbling
values, it is important to build on the embers of Yiddishkeit that are
still glowing in the heart of every Jew.
Dedicated by Gisele & Ira Beer in memory of Morris & Gisa Mayers
If you would like to be on a shiur update list which sends messagesregarding Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky's various lectures in NY City and LongIsland and other locations, please send a blank email firstname.lastname@example.org You will receive bulletins about those classes.
If you want to be on a shiur announcement faxlist, fax request along withyour fax number (dedicated line, please) to 516-569-7954