Hamaayan / The Torah Spring
Edited by Shlomo Katz
Volume XVIII, No. 12
16 Tevet 5764
January 10, 2004
Sponsored by Shlomo and Sharona Katz
in honor of the bar mitzvah of their son
Mrs. Helen Spector in memory of her father
Yisroel Zvi ben Moshe (Henry Greene) a"h
Daf Yomi (Bavli): Menachot 96
Daf Yomi (Yerushalmi): Yevamot 59
This parashah describes the Yaakov's final days and his burial. It then
relates that, after Yaakov's death, his sons were afraid that Yosef would
take revenge on them for selling him. The Torah relates that the brothers
therefore said to Yosef (in Yaakov's name), "Anah / Please, kindly forgive
the spiteful deed of your brothers and their sin, for they have done you
evil . . ."
The midrash (Yalkut Shimoni) quotes Hashem: "Because you prayed using the
word 'Anah,' the Kohen Gadol will, in the future, enter the Holy of Holies
and say, 'Anah Hashem'." Why?
R' Moshe Schwab z"l (1918-1979; Mashgiach of the Gateshead Yeshiva)
explains that the above verse from our parashah represents the first time
that Yosef's brothers recognized that they had sinned by selling
Yosef. (Although in Parashat Miketz they had blamed their troubles with
the Egyptian viceroy on their hardheartedness toward their brother's please
for mercy, they still believed that they were correct in selling
him.) Thus, in the continuation of their plea to Yosef, the brothers refer
to themselves as "the servants of your father's G-d," as if to say, "How
did we succeed in recognizing our sin? Because we employed the Divine
spark that is within us and raised ourselves above our prior
level." (Yosef responded, "Am I in place of G-d?" - as if to say humbly,
"I do not have a Divine spark equal to yours; I am but a tool in G-d's
hands, and I could never harm you.")
When the Kohen Gadol entered the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur and pleaded
for the Jewish people, he similarly said, "We have raised ourselves from
our prior level and therefore recognize that we have sinned. Please
respond by forgiving us." (Ma'archei Lev IV p.159)
"For I will lie down with my fathers . . ." (47:30)
R' Zalman of Volozhin z"l (see page 4) taught that this brief statement -
only three words in Hebrew - alludes to two fundamental beliefs of
Judaism. First, by referring to his impending death as "lying down," as
one lies down for a short nap, the patriarch Yaakov alluded to the eventual
resurrection of the dead. Second, by saying that he would be with his
fathers after his death, Yaakov alluded to the immortality of the soul, for
if the soul did not live on, how would he be with his fathers?
R' Zalman added that this demonstrates the importance of reading every word
of the Torah correctly. Since every word of the Torah is so pregnant with
meaning, one loses so much if he does not read the words carefully.
(Toldot Adam, Ch.4)
"Then Yisrael prostrated himself towards the head of the bed." (47:31)
Rashi explains that Yaakov bowed to show his gratitude to G-d that Yosef
had remained a tzaddik despite being a king and growing up in captivity
R' Shlomo Ganzfried z"l (died 1886; author of Kitzur Shulchan Aruch) asks:
Why did Rashi mention the two events in Yosef's life out of order? In
fact, first he grew up in captivity, and only afterwards he became [deputy]
R' Ganzfried explains that sometimes Hashem tests a person with poverty and
sometimes He tests a person with wealth. Which is a greater test? Wealth
is, because a poor person will by nature be humble. Therefore he is less
likely to rebel against G-d.
Yosef was tested with both wealth and poverty. Because wealth is the
greater test, Rashi mentions it first.
"He maneuvered his hands, for Menashe was the firstborn." (48:14)
This verse implies that the fact that Menashe was the firstborn was the
reason that Yaakov crossed his hands and placed his right hand on Ephraim's
head. In reality, however, the fact that Menashe was the firstborn was a
reason why Yaakov should not have crossed his hands, observes R' Yisrael
Isserlin z"l (died 1460; author of Terumat Ha'deshen). He offers two
First, R' Yisrael writes in the name of his grandfather, "The chassid, R'
Chaim, who was nicknamed Henschel of Heinbrucke, the son of our teacher, R'
Yisrael of Krems who wrote glosses on the Rosh": The verse means, "Yaakov
maneuvered his hands rather than embarrass Menashe by asking him to change
places with Ephraim, for Menashe was the firstborn." [Note: R' Yisrael's
reference to his great-grandfather and namesake is of historical interest
because it is the source for our ascribing authorship of the important
glosses on the Rosh to R' Yisrael of Krems. (Shem Hagedolim)]
Alternatively, we are taught that everything that happened to Yaakov had a
parallel in Yosef's life. Yaakov decided to bless Yosef's son, Ephraim, as
the first born just as Yaakov himself received the blessings of the
firstborn. In this light, the verse can be understood literally: "He
maneuvered his hands, for Menashe was the firstborn," and he did not wish
to bless the firstborn.
"Yaakov called for his sons and said, `Assemble yourselves and I will tell
you what will happen to you in the End of Days'." (49:1)
Yet, in the verse that follow, Yaakov does not tell his sons what will
happen to them in the "End of Days." Rather, he blesses them. Chazal
explain that Yaakov wanted to reveal the "kaitz" / the time for the arrival
of mashiach," but the Shechinah left him, so he changed the subject.
R' Yishayah of Tirani z"l (Italy; 13th century) asks: Why did Yaakov think
that his sons were worthy of knowing about the End of Days? Because they
were free of sin, i.e., among the names of the twelve sons of Yaakov, there
is no letter "chet" or "tet." Thus, there was no "chet" / "sin" among them.
Hashem responded: There also is no letter "tzadi" or "kuf" among the names
of Yaakov's twelve sons. Thus, there is no "kaitz" that can be revealed to
(Nimukei Chumash Le'Rabbeinu Yishayah)
"They came to Goren Ha'atad, which is across the Jordan, and there they
held a very great and imposing eulogy. . ." (50:10)
What is meant by "a very great and imposing eulogy"? Rabbeinu Chananel z"l
(Tunisia; 11th century) explains that there are nine different types of
eulogy, and this eulogy for Yaakov encompassed all of them. (R' Chananel
quotes verses in Tanach that illustrate the nine forms of eulogy.) There
also were nine groups of people accompanying Yaakov's body to Eretz
Yisrael, as we read in the preceding verses: "So (1) Yosef went up to bury
his father, and with him went up (2) all of Pharaoh's servants, (3) the
elders of his household, and (4) all the elders of the land of Egypt. And
(5) all of Yosef's household -- (6) his brothers, and (7) his father's
household . . . And he brought up with him both (8) chariots and (9)
What should a eulogy include? R' Chananel says: A eulogy should describe
the chessed and good deeds of the deceased, as in the verse (Shmuel II
1:23), "Shaul and Yehonatan, beloved and pleasant in their lives, and in
their death not parted . . ." (See also the verses which follow there.)
A eulogy also should bemoan the manner in which the subject died, as in the
verse (Shmuel II 3:33), "The king [David] lamented a dirge for Avner and
said, `Should Avner have died the death of a knave'." Also, a eulogy
should describe all the goodness that the deceased and now has lost, as in
the verse (Yechezkel 27:2-3), "Take up a lament for [the city of] Tyre . .
. `Your riches, and your wares, your merchandise, your rowers and your
sailors . . . and all the men of war who are within you, and with your
entire assembly that is in your midst, they will fall in the heart of the
seas on the day of your downfall'."
(Perushei Rabbeinu Chananel Al Ha'Torah)
R' Yehuda Braver z"l
R' Yehuda Braver was born in 1891 in a suburb of Vilna. His father, R'
Moshe Yitzchak, was a rabbi in several Lithuanian towns and, for the last
13 years of his life, in Cincinnati, Ohio. The younger R' Braver studied
in the Telshe Yeshiva under R' Yosef Leib Bloch, in Volozhin under R'
Raphael Shapiro, in Ponovezh under R' Yitzchak Yaakov Rabinowitz, and in
Vilna under R' Chaim Ozer Grodzenski. In 1913, R' Braver received semichah
from R' Shapiro. In that same year, he married and moved to the United States.
In America, R' Braver's first rabbinic position was in Akron, Ohio. There,
he worked to strengthen kashrut supervision, he built a Talmud Torah
building, and he established a branch of Mizrachi. (In 1922, he would be
elected President of Mizrachi of Ohio.) He also raised thousands of
dollars to support the settlement of Eretz Yisrael.
From 1923 to 1944, R' Braver was rabbi of the United Congregations of
Kansas City, an organization that included ten Orthodox synagogues in
Kansas City, Missouri and Kansas. There, too, he strengthened kashrut and
shechitah, and he built a modern mikveh that cost $20,000 (in 1920's
dollars). In 1935, he founded a yeshiva in Kansas City named Torat Moshe,
after his father. The yeshiva attracted students from many communities,
and R' Braver himself taught there four days a week in addition to bearing
the yeshiva's financial burdens. He was a fierce fighter against movements
that challenged Torah observance, and he called a convention of Orthodox
rabbis in Des Moines, Iowa that led to the founding of the Council of
Orthodox Rabbis of the Western States. R' Braver himself used to travel
through the western United States checking on kashrut standards and the
In 1944, R' Braver became Chief Rabbi of Mexico City, and he remained there
for four years. In Mexico City, as in his previous positions, R' Braver
strengthened kashrut and mikvaot. He also taught in that city's yeshiva,
Etz Chaim. In 1948, R' Braver took a position in Los Angeles.
R' Braver authored a number of works which remained in manuscript after his
death. These included She'eilot U'teshuvot Gur Aryeh Yehuda (halachic
responsa) and Divrei Yehuda (sermons). (Toldot Anshei Shem p.12)
Copyright © 2004 by Shlomo Katz
The editors hope these brief 'snippets' will engender further study
and discussion of Torah topics ("lehagdil Torah u'leha'adirah"), and
your letters are appreciated. Web archives at Torah.org
start with 5758 (1997) and
may be retrieved from the Hamaayan page.
Text archives from 1990 through the present
may be retrieved from
to HaMaayan are tax-deductible.