But Who's Counting?
Volume 26, No. 30
King Shlomo writes in Mishlei (16:11), “A peles / scale and moznai mishpat /
just balances are Hashem’s; His deeds are like even kis / weights in a
pouch.” Rabbeinu Bachya z”l (Spain; 14th century) explains: King Shlomo
intends to teach us that all of man’s deeds are weighed, and that Hashem has
all sizes of weights. A peles is a large scale, moznaim are somewhat
smaller, and weights that can fit in a pouch represent the smallest units of
measurement. This is all a metaphor to teach that G-d weighs and punishes
for the smallest sins and for major sins; He forgets nothing. This idea is
conveyed as well in the verse (Yirmiyah 16:16), “Behold, I shall send many
fishermen--so says Hashem--and they will fish them out, and afterwards I
will send many trappers and they will trap them from atop every mountain and
every hill and from the crevices in the rocks.” This is like a person who
empties a room and then goes back to make sure he left nothing behind. So,
too, Hashem forgets nothing. [Ed. note: R’ Bachya does not mean to discount
the possibility of teshuvah. Rather, he is warning a person not to think
that “small” sins don’t matter.]
Perhaps, R’ Bachya continues, the small weights are said to be kept in a
pouch to allude to the mystery that is inherent in Hashem’s judgment. In
reality, we often don’t know what He considers to be a “big” sin or a
“small” sin. This is alluded to in the verse (Tehilim 36:7), “Your charity
is like the mighty mountains; Your judgment is like the deep waters.”
R’ Bachya notes that, according to the just-quoted verse, unlike Hashem’s
judgment which is concealed like the depths, His charity is in the open like
the mountains. For example, in the Book of Yechezkel, the date of the
destruction of the Temple, a manifestation of Hashem’s judgment, is hidden
in confusing terms. In contrast, in our parashah, all of the details of the
census, which demonstrates Hashem’s love for us (i.e., His charity) are
spelled out. (Beur Al Ha’Torah)
“They established their genealogy according to their families . . .” (1:18)
The prophet Yechezkel quotes Hashem as comparing the Jewish People to
plants, saying (Yechezkel 16:1), “I made you as numerous as the plants of
the field; you increased and grew . . .” R’ Yitzchak Isaac Chaver z”l
(1789-1852; rabbi of Suvalk, Lithuania) explains that there are a number of
similarities between the Jewish People and the plant world.
(1) The more a farmer works his field, the better his plants will grow.
Similarly, we read about Bnei Yisrael in Egypt (Shmot 1:12), “But, the more
they would afflict it [the Jewish People], so it would increase and so it
would spread out.”
(2) G-d created numerous species of plants, and they continue to reproduce
within their own species. Likewise, we read (in our verse), “They
established their genealogy according to their families”--a testament that
Bnei Yisrael in Egypt did not intermarry.
(3) Most plants have a season when they blossom and a season when they
wither. Similarly, the Jewish People have periods of exile and periods of
redemption, regarding which we read (Shir Ha’shirim 2:11-12), “For the
winter has passed, the deluge is over and gone. The blossoms are seen in
the land, the time of song has arrived . . .” [As Rashi z”l explains, “For
the winter of bondage has passed, the deluge of suffering is over and gone .
. .”] (Haggadah Shel Pesach Yad Mitzrayim)
From the same work:
“The Ohel Mo’ed, the camp of the Levi’im, shall journey in the middle of the
R’ Yitzchak Isaac Chaver writes: The tribe of Levi [the teachers of Torah;
see Devarim 33:10] was the heart of Bnei Yisrael. Therefore, they were
surrounded by four camps, as a person’s torso is surrounded by his two arms
and two legs.
R’ Chaver continues: Including Levi--and counting Yosef’s sons, Menashe and
Ephraim, separately--there were 13 tribes. Not coincidentally, there are 13
months (in a leap year); 13 gates, 13 tables, and 13 pushkes in the Bet
Hamikdash; a visitor to the Bet Hamikdash bowed down in 13 places; Hashem
spoke to the Patriarchs 13 times; there are 13 Attributes of Mercy; and
there are 13 covenants.
Lastly, there also are 13 rules to be used when interpreting the Torah. R’
Chaver explains the relationship between the last three of these “thirteens”
as follows: Our ability to interpret the Torah is a reflection of Hashem’s
desire to reveal His Will to us, which, in turn, is an outgrowth of His
covenant with the Patriarchs. And, because of that close relationship, He
revealed to Moshe Rabbeinu “His ways” (see Shmot 33:13), i.e., His
attributes of Mercy.
“Five acquisitions the Holy One, Blessed Is He, acquired for Himself in His
world, and they are: the Torah, one acquisition; heaven and earth, one
acquisition; Avraham, one acquisition; Yisrael, one acquisition; the Bet
Hamikdash, one acquisition.” (Chapter 6)
R’ Yitzchak Berachiah Mi’Fano z”l (Italy; 1583-1658) asks: From whom did He
acquire these five things? Indeed, what does it mean that Hashem acquired
something when everything in the world already is His?
He explains: It is G-d’s desire that man have free will so that the
righteous will earn reward. (It follows, also, that the wicked earn
punishments by misusing their free will.) A strong argument could be made
that man’s exercise of his free will should be unlimited, even to the point
that he could destroy the world if he chose. However, the five things
listed in our mishnah are so precious to G-d that He took steps to protect
them without limiting man’s free will. In this sense, He “acquired” them
back from mankind.
How so? [A full explanation of all five “acquisitions” would not fit in the
available space, but we present two examples.] R’ Yitzchak Berachiah
continues, Hashem knows that the Torah is best off in the hands of the
descendants of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov. Still, fairness required
Hashem to offer the Torah to all of the nations. What did He do? The
midrash says that, when Hashem offered the Torah to each nation, it asked
what is in the Torah. Hashem answered one nation, “Do not steal,” another,
“Do not commit adultery,” etc. R’ Yitzchak Berachiah explains that He
answered each with a detail that that particular nation would find
unpalatable. He did this with the intention of discouraging them. Each of
those nations still had the free will to overcome its nature and accept the
Torah. The end result, however, was that Hashem “acquired” the Torah back
to give to the nation that He knows is the most appropriate recipient.
Another example: Avraham Avinu was born into a family steeped in idol
worship. Left alone, Avraham would have been no different than his father
Terach, exactly what that wicked generation would have wanted. Hashem did
not negate their free will. He did, however, give Avraham an opening, as
the prophet says (Yeshayah 41:2–the haftarah for Parashat Lech Lecha), “Who
aroused [Avraham] from the east, who would proclaim His righteousness at
every footstep?” By “awakening” Avraham, Hashem “acquired” him for His
purposes, but Avraham did the rest using his free will. (Chanoch La’na’ar)
Letters from Our Sages
R’ Naftali Zvi Yehuda Berlin z”l (the “Netziv”; 1816-1893) was rabbi of
Volozhin, Russia and rosh yeshiva of the yeshiva there, as well as the
author of many Torah works. In this letter, published in Igrot Ha’Netziv
Mi’Volozhin p.42, he responds to someone who had critiqued one of his works.
Regarding your apology, stating that you do not mean your critique to hurt
my feelings, G-d forbid that I would think such a thought about your honor.
To the contrary, I derive satisfaction from anyone who clarifies and
corrects my mistakes--mistakes being something that even those greater than
Regarding this, I suggest the following interpretation of the verse (Kohelet
10:1), “Dead flies putrefy, yabia the perfumer's oil; a little folly
outweighs wisdom and honor.” The word “yabia” is obscure. Also, according
to the pshat / plain meaning, it is difficult to connect the parts of this
verse. I suggest that, in this context, “yabia” means “to publicize.” The
verse is teaching that, while flies do spoil the perfume in which they land,
they also perform a kindness by publicizing the perfume’s attractiveness.
Likewise, while a little ignorance, i.e., a mistake, does sully a Torah
work, the fact that people draw attention to that mistake and critique it
makes it a better work.
It is well known how happy a person feels when he knows that great people
read his words. Our Sages [Yevamot 97a] teach that even those who are
deceased derive pleasure from their words of Torah being quoted. If those
who know no physical pleasure or honor feel such, how much more so, then,
does a living person enjoy this!
Therefore, I owe a debt of gratitude to your honor, and to anyone who looks
at my works Emek She’eilah and Ha’amek Davar. In this merit, may Hashem
come to their aid and may their words enlighten their generation. [I give
you] the blessing of your friend who is weighed down with avodah.
The editors hope these brief 'snippets' will engender further study
and discussion of Torah topics ('lehagdil Torah u'leha'adirah'), and
your letters are appreciated. Web archives at Torah.org start with 5758 (1997) and
may be retrieved from the Hamaayan page.
Hamaayan needs your support! Please consider sponsoring Hamaayan in honor of a happy occasion or in memory of a loved one. The low cost of sponsorship is $36. Donations to HaMaayan are tax-deductible.
TAZRIA AND METZORAH:
Good News and Bad News
Rabbi Label Lam - 5772
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5770
Something Like An Affliction Has Appeared On My House
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5774
Who Is The Man Who Wants To PRESERVE Life?
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5772
Living on the End
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5760
Rabbi Raymond Beyda - 5765
Speaking Ill of Others
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5758
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5761
Battling The Serpent
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5766
Nipping the Quip
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5758
Learning A Lesson From G-d Through Punishment
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5768
Only a Verbal Agreement?
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5757
Not Afflicted, Still Affected
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5763
Shemiras Halashon and Pesach
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5774
The Gossip of "Men of Distinction"
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5760
Living for the Moment
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5762