Can a son lie to father to get to class on time?
QUESTION 13 - CAN A SON LIE TO A FATHER
TO GET TO A CLASS ON TIME?
Let's say a boy knows that his father is often late.
If he depends on his father to get to an evening
class on time, and he wants to be sure to get
there on time, can he tell his father that it
starts earlier than it really does?
RABBI BELSKY'S ANSWER
I think the answer is yes. The boy knows that if
he tells his father that the class starts at 7:10,
when, in fact, it starts at 7:10, he will never get
there on time. So he can tell his father that the
class starts at 7:00, because in his father's mind
7:00 means 7:10.
It seems from the Talmud, though, that there may be
a problem. It says in the Talmud that Rav had a wife
who was very tough. Rav used to eat two kinds of foods,
beans and lentils. When he asked his wife for lentils,
she gave him beans; when he asked for beans, she gave
him lentils. She always did the opposite of what he
asked for, just to cause him grief. Perhaps this was
because it was a rabbonishe (Rabbi) household, where
guests always came and went, and Rav and his wife were
always busy, with a million things to do. Whatever the
cause, that's what Chazal (the Sages), tell us.
The Talmud goes on to say that after many years, Rav
asked his son, "Go into the kitchen and bring some
lentils." So the son went to the mother and said,
"My father wants beans." So she made lentils and gave
it to him. So Rav said, "Look, the might of the son
is greater than the might of the father. You were
able to do what I wasn't successful at doing for the
last twenty years." So the son said, "No, I'll tell
you the truth. I asked her for beans, so that she
would give you lentils."
Rav said, "You shouldn't do that. It says Limdo
l'shonom darkei sheker (If you tell a lie, you end
up becoming a liar)."
Here, however, it is different. There are two different
time zones here. If a person in Israel tells you the
time is 12:30 AM, you have to adjust, and subtract seven
hours. It's really 5:30 p.m. here. The same thing applies
to this case. When the father is told that the class begins
at 7:10, in his mind he could be interpreting it that he
hould leave the house at 7:10. So by his son saying "7:00",
his father will think, "I should leave the house at 7:00",
and then the son will get to the class on time at 7:10.
There may be some other time warp here, with the same
result, i.e. saying 7:00 produces a 7:10 effect in the
other person's mind. But be careful, there may be a risk
that the son is violating the trust of his father.
NEXT WEEK'S QUESTION 14: CALLLING HOME COLLECT WITH
A FICTICOUS NAME TO SAY THAT YOU HAVE ARRIVED
If a person is going on a trip, and he wants to
inform someone that he's arrived safely, is it
permissible to make a call with a fictitious name
as a signal to the other person?
NEXT WEEK'S QUESTION 15: HOW STRICT TO ABIDE BY
'TRIAL PERIOD' OF SHAREWARE SOFTWARE
Some software that can be downloaded for free
from the Internet comes with a provision that it
is free only for an "evaluation period", let's say
for thirty days, after which the software must be
bought or destroyed. How strictly must one abide
by this provision?
Participate in the Honesty Forum, and discuss the issues we confront in this class!
Subscribe to Honesty and receive this class via e-