To Save a Life
By Rabbi Daniel Travis
...eventually I will reach you, my lord, in Seir. (Bereshith 33:14)
Yaakov never intended to travel as far as Seir, for his destination was the
closer region of Succoth. Yet, he reasoned, by telling Esav that he would
eventually reach Seir, he might save himself and his family, for if Esav
was planning to do him harm, there was a chance that he would choose to
wait until Yaakov reached Seir, where he thought they would meet again.1
Our Sages learn from Yaakov's conduct in this situation that if a traveler
finds himself accompanied by shady characters, he should give them the
impression that he is traveling somewhere other than his actual destination.2
These are situations of potential danger, for it is not clear whether the
travelers' lives are actually threatened by those accompanying them.
Moreover, even if there is a definite threat to one's safety, there is no
guarantee that telling someone a fabricated destination will spare a
traveler from harm. Still, if there is any chance at all, no matter how
small, of saving a life, one may tell an untruth, because the preservation
of life is of primary importance and it supercedes almost all other concerns.3
During the Holocaust, the Gestapo once came to the home of a German family
who had been hiding Jews. Asked whether there were any Jews in their house,
the family replied that there were. As the soldiers were dragging the Jews
off, the German family self-righteously explained that a false word had
never left their lips, and they were not about to begin to lie now.3
The desire to tell the truth in no way justifies the German family's
actions, for in reality, there can be no greater perversion of truth than
forfeiting another's life by handing him over to murderers. The potential
danger would have justified Yaakov's mentioning a false destination;
nevertheless he spoke with an element of truth when he mentioned reaching
Seir. He was alluding to the future redemption of the Jewish People, when
the Messiah will go to Mount Zion to judge Mount Seir (in the inheritance
of Esav).4 From Yaakov's example we see that even under life-threatening
circumstances one should try to remain as close to the truth as possible.
1. Rashi on Bereshith 33:14.
2. Avodah Zara 25b; Shulchan Aruch Yoreh De'ah 153:3.
3. Heard in the name of Rav Matisyahu Solomon.
4. Bereshith Rabbah 78:18.
Priceless Integrity, Copyright © 2003 by Rabbi Daniel Travis and Torah.org.
Subscribe to Priceless Integrity and receive the class via e-mail.