In the past weeks we have discussed various commandments that are related
to speech, such as lashon hara. Another, less well-known command relating
to speech is the prohibition of ‘hurtful words’, (Onas Devarim in
Hebrew).There is a well-known saying that, “sticks and stones might break
my bones but words can never hurt me.” This is not the Torah approach;
speech is a very powerful tool that can be used to cause great good or
great harm. In a certain way, harmful speech can actually do more damage
than causing physical pain because speech can penetrate deep into a
person’s inner being. Anyone involved in a long relationship can testify
that a few harsh words can be remembered for several years.
There are a number of different forms of Onas Devarim. The most obvious
is speaking harshly to a person. It is forbidden to speak in such a way
that will cause emotional damage to a person. Thus, raising one’s voice,
or shouting are forms of speech that are almost always prohibited. A
person may feel that he has the right to shout at this children and there
may be very rare occasions when it may be appropriate, however, as a rule
one should never shout at his children1 . Shouting may achieve an immediate goal but the long-
term results are invariably negative.
It seems that the closer we are with people, the more likely we are to
speak hurtfully to them. Thus, a husband and wife may often speak to each
other in such a way that they would never dream of speaking to strangers.
This is of course extremely damaging - there is no need to speak harshly
to one’s spouse. Even if we feel that it is necessary to criticize them
in some way, doing so in a harsh way invariably fails. Only speaking
softly, and sharing one’s feelings will have any chance of success2 .
There are times where we may feel it necessary to offer constructive
criticism to someone. In order for such criticism to have any chance of
its success working it must be said over in a gentle and humble way.
People are generally very sensitive to any criticism but if it is done in
as unthreatening way then the person is far more likely to accept it.
However, when a person feels he is being verbally attacked he will be
placed on the defensive and will not accept what he is being told.
1 Moreover, on the rare occasions where it may be permitted to
speak harshly to one’s children, one is NEVER allowed to shout at them
from a sense of anger, only if one‘s motivations are completely pure.
2 It should be noted that many marriage experts suggest that
the best way of changing one’s spouse for the better is to change
ourselves first. When they see that we are treating them with respect,
then they are far more likely to reciprocate.
Text Copyright © 2008 by Rabbi Yehonasan Gefen and Torah.org