by Rabbi Yaakov Menken
"G-d spoke to Moses, saying: 'Command the Children of Israel, and say to
them, "My food sacrifices, for My fire, My pleasing fragrance, you shall
guard to bring to Me in its proper time."'" [28:1-2]
Immediately following the appointment of Yehoshuah, Joshua, as Moshe's
successor, the Torah turns to the congregational offerings -- the daily,
Sabbath and holiday sacrifices. What is the connection? Why are this
presented now, rather than, for example, in Leviticus? There, the
sacrifices offered by individuals are described. The holidays are
discussed, and there is even an allusion to the sacrifices detailed here.
So there must be a reason why the Torah waited until now.
One answer, provided by the Leket Bahir, is that the sacrifices are part of
inheriting the Land of Israel. In this week's reading, the appointment of
Yehoshuah follows a discussion of the laws of inheritance of land.
Yehoshuah is then appointed as the leader who will bring the Children of
Israel into that Land, so they are prepared to enter. The Leket Bahir
explains that our occupation of the land was in the merit of the sacrifices
which we would offer while there, and the connection to G-d thereby expressed.
The Sfas Emes and Rabbi Shamshon Raphael Hirsch both suggest a different
answer -- that, in fact, the sacrifices were a component of the succession,
the continuation of leadership after Moshe.
The Sfas Emes writes that we must remember the giving of the Torah, in both
word and action, every day. We said on Mt. Sinai, "we will do, and we will
listen." We listen, or express the giving of the Torah in words, when we
recite the Shema: "Hear O Israel, the L-rd our G-d, the L-rd is One," and
the paragraphs which follow. What is our action? During Moshe's lifetime,
he himself was a walking source of Torah. Going to him, following his
instruction, was acting to remember the giving of Torah, for it was he who
taught G-d's Torah to us. After Moshe, it was the sacrifices which acted to
strengthen and remind us of our connection to G-d who gave us the Torah.
Performance of those sacrifices was the action.
Rav Hirsch focuses somewhat differently upon this same component of our
relationship with Moshe, which could not be duplicated through Yehoshuah.
He writes that Moshe ensured the appointment of a successor, so that "the
People of G-d should not remain without a leader who would shine in front
of them as a model for private and public life, and who would... guide and
keep the individual and communal life of the people in the paths indicated
"But that the people and their leaders should never come to lose this,
their calling, that Israel should always keep in mind their never-ending
mission, their relations to G-d from His special guiding of their fate, and
their obligations, and taking these ever afresh to heart, for that the
procedures of the national offerings which follow here, are to be
effective." [from the English translation by Isaac Levy]
Maimonides writes in his Laws of Prayer that although there is a Torah
obligation to pray every day, it was the Rabbis who established the order
of prayers, following the order of the sacrifices: three daily prayers plus
an additional prayer on Sabbath and holidays, like the sacrifices. This is
in accordance with the words of the prophet Hoshea [14:3], "let our lips
substitute for bulls."
Prayer is our connection, our reminder. It is so powerful that it can be
not merely speech, but the equivalent of action -- if we put ourselves into
it and concentrate upon it.
Someone wisely commented that when one is in the habit of praying daily, it
then becomes so much easier to do when one feels the most urgent need.
"There are no athiests in the foxholes" -- but when one suddenly finds an
urgent reason to speak with G-d, one must know what to say!
There was a tank unit in the Yom Kippur war composed primarily, but not
exclusively, of hesder-yeshiva students, who studied and performed military
service together over a period of five years. In one tank, all but the
gunner were yeshiva students -- the gunner himself was a secularist, who
teased his comrades for their "silly" devotion to observance, study and
During one momentous battle, they crested a hill only to discover an array
of Arab tanks waiting for them at the bottom. They frantically radioed back
and attempted to reverse direction, but in the next second one track of the
tank was hit, and they were disabled. Death loomed before them.
In a panic, the gunner screamed out: "Shema Yisrael... I don't know the
rest! Shema Yisrael, I don't know the rest!"
One second later, a grappling hook latched on to their tank, and they were
pulled back over the hill.
Let us pray, and mean it, now -- and not wait for such a horrible time to
Rabbi Yaakov Menken
About the Author