by Rabbi Yaakov Menken
"Speak to the Children of Israel and say to them: 'the festivals of G-d
which you shall announce, the Holy Gatherings, these are My festivals. Six
days shall you do labor, and on the seventh day, it is a Holy Sabbath, a
Holy Gathering; you shall not do any labor, it is the Sabbath to G-d
throughout your dwellings.'" [23:2-3]
What is puzzling about this is that the Torah begins to discuss the
holidays, the "appointed times," and immediately turns instead to the
Sabbath day. The holidays were "announced," because they fall on particular
days of the month. The New Moon was proclaimed by the Sanhedrin, the
Supreme Rabbinical Court in the Temple, and signals or messengers had to be
sent out to announce the new month so that people would know when to
celebrate the next holiday. The Sabbath, by contrast, falls every seven
days -- it needs no announcement. So how, then, can the Torah include it
among "the festivals of G-d which you shall announce?"
The Vilna Gaon, Rabbi Eliyahu Kramer, had a wonderfully creative answer to
this question. He said that this passage is not talking about the Sabbath
at all. According to the Torah, there are six holidays during which the
labors necessary to prepare food are permitted: one day of Rosh HaShanah,
Sukkos and Shemini Atzeres (the "eighth day" immediately after Sukkos), the
first and last days of Pesach, and Shavuos. With the exception of Rosh
HaShanah (again related to the declaration of the new months in the
Sanhedrin), all of these are celebrated in the Land of Israel for one day
So during all of these six days, one may do labor -- as necessary to
prepare food. The seventh holiday, however, is Yom Kippur -- called a
"Shabbos Shabbason," a Sabbath of rest -- and on Yom Kippur all labor is
prohibited! So this, said Rabbi Kramer, is the Holy Sabbath intended by
this verse -- the day of Yom Kippur!
Nonetheless, a straightforward explanation of this verse is that we are
indeed discussing the Sabbath day, and that Shabbos is indeed tied to the
holidays at a very fundamental level.
Shabbos reminds us that "these are My festivals" -- they are G-d's. Because
the Sanhedrin announces the New Moon, and thus tells us when the holidays
will fall in a given year, we might think that they are merely "ours" --
holidays of commemoration, remembrance. They are much more than that. The
holidays are HaShem's, days when HaShem renews special connections between
the world and aspects of Holiness. On Passover, our Sages teach that it is
easier than other times to break the ties that imprison us to our evil
inclination. On Shavuos, there is a special connection between the Jews and
the Torah. We are not simply commemorating for millenia something that
happened one year -- we re-experience a spirit that comes back every year
at that time.
Shabbos is our reminder that this is so. Shabbos is not dependent upon
human beings and the Sanhedrin's decisions -- yet this, too, is a festival.
If the holiness of the Sabbath returns every week, this reminds us that the
holiness of the festivals returns every year.
In the prayers and Kiddush for a holiday which falls on Shabbos, we praise
G-d "Who Sanctifies the Sabbath, Israel and the Appointed Times." The order
of these three speaks to this distinction between Sabbath and the other
holidays. HaShem sanctifies the Sabbath -- He alone. He sanctifies Israel
-- and then He and Israel together determine when the sanctity of the
holidays shall come to the world.
When I was a college student, it turned out one year that Freshman
Orientation Week was to begin on Monday -- the first day of Rosh HaShanah.
As you might imagine, this was greeted with much dismay by Jewish students.
After much discussion the school administration decided to accommodate
Jewish freshmen -- by moving the first day of orientation two days earlier,
Every week of the year, we have the opportunity to celebrate, to rejoice,
to experience the special relationship between G-d and the Jewish people.
The Sabbath is certainly no less a holiday than all of the others that come
but once per year, and one that speaks to the nature of all the holidays.
The fact that it comes so often only means we are very fortunate -- if we
make the most of this opportunity!
A Good Shabbos,
Rabbi Yaakov Menken
About the Author