by Rabbi Yaakov Menken
"They gathered together against Moses and Aaron, and they said to them,
'you have taken too much for yourselves, for the entire nation is comprised
of holy individuals, and G-d dwells among them - why, then, have you lifted
yourselves above the Congregation of G-d?'" [16:3]
This is what Korach and his group said to Moshe and Aaron. And you know
what? For much of what he said, Korach was right: the Jewish people are
indeed a holy nation, designated to serve G-d. All of us have a connection
to G-d as human beings, and the Jewish people have a special responsibility
and special connection as His Nation, the recipients of His Torah. As
Korach put it in the original holy tongue, all of the nation are
"Kedoshim," which means holy and also distinct, designated. We have a
purpose to fulfill.
This, however, does not mean that we have no need for guidance. To say that
because everyone is holy, everyone can decide for themselves what is
correct, makes no sense. We need guidance, and teaching.
The best way to learn to use or program a computer is to simply try various
things, with a manual close at hand. If something doesn't work, you just
try something else. This approach works well because computers provide
instant feedback -- if something doesn't work, you know very quickly. In
addition, assuming you are working on a development platform, there are no
major consequences if something fails. Do-it-yourself learning is a fine
approach -- yet even so, one always benefits when we can ask advice of
others with greater expertise.
Now imagine trying to learn to practice medicine the same way. If someone
came in with a serious ailment, we would simply try one medicine after the
other until one appeared to work. How many patients would die before we got
it right? The feedback is not fast enough, and the consequences of wrong
decisions are too grave, to attempt such an approach. In medicine, careful
training and expert guidance are that much more important. One who
approached this field with the arrogance of a hacker would be a murderer!
In spiritual matters, we are not sufficiently in touch with the higher
realms to recognize immediate feedback from our actions. According to
Jewish thought, there are certainly immediate ramifications. When we do
mitzvos, we create angels. But, and this is very important, we don't see
them. We don't know.
Are we doing G-d's will, or not? How do we know? The answer, of course, is
through our teachers. The Torah guides us, but the Torah's wisdom is locked
in a chain of tradition. If everyone decides how he or she will interact
with G-d, then the result is no dialogue, but a monologue. Such a person
ends up worshipping himself.
The Chapters of the Fathers, Pirkei Avos, teach us [1:6]: "Yehoshua ben
Prachya says: make a teacher for yourself." This even precedes acquiring a
friend or partner in learning and growth. Rabbeinu Yonah explains in his
commentary that you should even acquire a teacher if you know as much as
he. _Make_ someone your teacher nonetheless, he says, for a person is more
likely to remember that which he has been taught, and may find that the
other party has better understood a topic.
Moshe and Aharon did not lift themselves up; rather, G-d placed them in
that position. The nation needed teachers, and we need teachers and
guidance today, in order to rise to our full potential.
Rabbi Yaakov Menken
Text Copyright © 2002 Project Genesis, Inc.
The author is the Director of Project Genesis.