The gentiles challenged the Jewish people about the Parah Adumah, Red Cow
that is the archetypal Chok, a mitzvah whose meaning is a mystery. The
classical Jewish response to this attack was: "It is a decree issued onto
me. You have no right to question this!" (Rashi, Bamidbar 19:2).
Human understanding can never be the determining factor when it comes to
mitzvah observance. Torah is the life-force of creation. Thus, it could
not rest upon the acceptance of man – whose selection today does not
preclude his subsequent de-selection tomorrow. That is why in spite of the
Jewish readiness to embrace the Torah, as immortalized in their
proclamation naaseh v'nishma, "we will do and we will understand" (Shemos
24:7), nevertheless G-d coerced them to accept the Torah or else face
destruction (Shabbos 88a).
Every mitzvah is by "royal appointment".
Every one of the 613 commandments is a divine decree of the Supreme King
whose edict is to be obeyed come-what-may. The mitzvah as the loyal
fulfilment of the king's decree is reason enough.
The Maharal (Tiferes Yisrael Ch.6) explains how the underlying principle
of mitzvah performance is for man is to connect to G-d on His terms.
A Jew's outlook to a mitzvah has to be from the viewpoint of G-d, not man.
That means his starting point to mitzvah observance cannot be because it
appeals to his rationale, because of its societal impact, because he
relates to its beauty, because of the benefits involved, or even because
of the reward promised. Were this to be the case, this attitude would
render observance on man's terms.
This is profoundly unacceptable because it undermines the metaphysical
properties of the Infinite, transcendental world of Torah. Worse still, it
drags the exalted word of G-d down onto the infinitesimal level of man,
where it loses its "divine quality" and becomes subject to the scrutiny of
the prevailing human standards and prejudices.
By contrast, where the underlying factor is of man fulfilling the divine
command, the Jew supernaturally transcends his physical existence to
develop an eternal relationship with G-d; man exclusively relates to Him
where it is on His terms. This all-important element is prominently
missing where the "decider" or determining factor is man himself.
When the focus is doing a mitzvah that comes from Him because of Him,
there is no danger or concern lest one misconstrue the commandments as
residing in man's domain. The Jew dares not tamper or humanize the mitzvah
in any manner whatsoever. Instead, He strives to be "like a servant who
observes the master's directive with no concern of the reward" (Avos 1:3).
There is no self-interest or personal motives in the knowledge "the
commandments were not given for [man's] benefit" (Nedarim 16b).
Whatever the benefits and goodness that mitzvah observance bring, the Jew
never loses sight that he exists merely to advance the prestige of his
Creator, not his own.
Nor does he overlook how the 613 commandments are "by royal appointment".
The course is presented by Osher Chaim Levene, author of SET IN STONE (2004: Targum) about the meaning of mitzvah observance and PEOPLE OF THE BOOK (2007: Targum) about the biblical personalities. A London-based writer and educator whose website www.mitzva.org explores the wisdom of the commandments, he learned at the Gateshead and Mir Yeshivas, holds a Bachelor of Science (Honors) business degree from London's City University, and is a Member of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors.