Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann
Shmitah - You Better Believe!
Parshas Behar begins with the mitzvah of shemitah, which requires
that any Jew owning land which he cultivates for produce allow his
land a year-long rest once in every seven years, during which all types
of land-related work are forbidden. This one-year rest period, which
was observed simultaneously by all Jews in the Land of Israel, could
presumably create a potential shortage of produce in Israel. Indeed,
the Torah addresses this question [25:20]:
"And if you will ask: 'What will we eat during
the seventh year? Behold - we will not sow
[our fields], nor gather in our crops!'"
In anticipation of this question, Hashem answers [v. 21]: Do not
"For I will command My blessing for you
during the sixth year, and it [the sixth year]
will yield a crop [sufficient] for the entire three
years." [Rashi explains that the produce of the
sixth year was used over a three year period:
the second half of the sixth year, the seventh
year, and the first half of the eighth year.]
We know that not even one word of the Torah is unnecessary or
superfluous. Why does the Torah give the promise of abundant crops
in the sixth year only in answer to an anticipated question which Jews
may or may not ask? Why doesn't the Torah simply promise a
berachah, a blessing, to the crops of the sixth year - thereby resolving
all potential difficulties?
The Rebbe R' Elimelech of Liezensk zt"l, in answer to this question,
quotes his brother, the holy Rebbe R' Zusia of Anipoli zt"l. Hashem
created the world, says R' Zusia, in such a manner that every creature
has its needs taken care of. In the words of the Mishnah (Kiddushin
Rabbi Shimon ben Elazar says: "Have you ever
seen an animal or a bird with a 'profession?'
Yet they all receive their sustenance without
The ant sustains itself without great effort. The birds, the animals,
and the insects; all manage to survive comfortably. So, too, the world
was created that man should be able to support himself with relative
ease. Were we, says R' Zusia, to truly and wholeheartedly believe that
Hashem provides for us, and that that which we do to earn a living
is merely the minimal effort required on our behalf, then we would
indeed be blessed with a life of relative ease, and all our needs would
be taken care of without having to extend great effort.
When, however, we doubt Hashem, when we question His ability to
provide for us, this "ruptures" the spiritual paths through which our
sustenance reaches us from Above. We find ourselves unable to earn
a living and sustain ourselves without great effort and exertion.
This, he says, is alluded to in the above passage. And if you will ask,
"What will we eat in the seventh year... " Asking is an expression of
doubt. By asking, instead of simply placing our trust in Hashem, we
damage the "paths of sustenance." It should have been easy, but now
it can not be easy because failed trust with conviction. Even so,
Hashem will not forsake you. I will command My blessing for you
in the sixth year... A special blessing will be given to repair the
damage done by our lack of simple faith.
Mefarshim (Torah commentators) note that it is strange that the
question asked is, What will we eat in the seventh year? Normally
in the seventh year, the Jews of Israel would eat the crops of the sixth
year, which was a standard year of planting and harvest. What were
they concerned about in the seventh year? If anything, their concern
should have been over the eighth year, which would normally be
sustained by the crops of the seventh year!
A wealthy businessman once sunk most of his considerable assets
into a lumber venture. The lumber was to be transported by floating
it down the Dneiper River, an economical but somewhat risky
The man came to the Netziv, Rabbi Naftali Tvi Berlin zt"l for a
berachah (blessing) that all should go well. The Netziv told him to
have bitachon (faith) in Hashem, Who will certainly help him.
"Of course I know that I should have bitachon," the man said. "But
what can I do - I am still extremely nervous!"
"You know," said the Netziv, "now I understand a passage in the
Torah that has always bothered me. The Torah says the Jews will
ask, 'How can we keep Shemitah? What will we eat on the seventh
year?' One wonders: Why were they so concerned over the seventh
year? Didn't they prepare for it in the sixth year? They should have
been concerned over the eighth year!
"Let us consider, however, to whom the Torah is speaking -
instructing them not to worry and to have bitachon. Certainly it is not
to the poor, firstly because they are already used to relying on
bitachon, and secondly because they own no land. Rather, the Torah
must be speaking to the wealthy landowners, who are used to
'earning their own living,' and are not connected with bitachon on a
regular basis. They can't believe they can survive without their active
participation, without "doing it themselves!" This is why they are
already nervous, even for the seventh year.
"Don't worry," concluded the Netziv. "Have true bitachon, and all will
Text Copyright © 2000 Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann and Project Genesis, Inc.