Debarim, the last of the 5 books of Moses, contains the words of rebuke
and encouragement given by Moshe to his people in the last days of his
illustrious life. As he tells of the highlights of the Israelite's travels
over the 40 years in the desert, the tale of the spies surfaces as a key
turning point in the history of our people. At the request of the masses
with the consent of G-d, Moshe agrees to send a group of righteous leaders,
one from each tribe, to investigate the nature of the Promised Land and its
inhabitants. Supposedly, with the information in hand, a strategy for
conquering the land would then be devised. But history would not work out
planned. The spies returned with a negative, fear instilling report. ''The
land is good, but the inhabitants are just too strong for us to conquer and
remove from the land", they announced. The people started to cry and then
rebel in spite of the assurances of Yehoshua and Caleb. Hashem in His anger
decided to kill off the entire generation during 40 years of wandering in
the desert before allowing their children to enter the land as conquerors.
"Tonight you cried for no reason" He declared, "therefore, you will cry for
generations on this night."
And so it has been for thousands of years --the mazal--luck-- of the
Jewish people has been bad on that night-- the night of Tisha B'Ab. The
first and the second Temple were destroyed by gentile armies --on Tisha
B'Ab. The city of Bitar was raped and pillaged and hundreds of thousands of
our gentle brethren were slaughtered on Tisha B'Ab. The Jews were expelled
from Spain and England--on the night of Tisha B'Ab. The terrible history of
the destruction of Judaism in Europe at the hands of the Nazis y''s, began
with the political upheaval of World War I, which, not coincidentally,
on the night of Tisha B'Ab in 1914.
What connection is there between the sin of the spies and the
destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem? What can we do to right the wrong
and end the exile that we have been suffering for 1937 years?
Our Sages explain that the people, who lived at the time of the
Temple's destruction by the Romans learned Torah, did misvot and performed
acts of kindness. Why was the Temple destroyed? Because of sin' at
hinam--baseless hatred. Jealousy and selfishness created differences in
people. ''Why does he drive such a nice car and I pray that mine will start
every time that I put the key in the ignition?''--''I work so hard and do
everything with impeccable honesty, so how come his business is flying and
mine can't show a profit?'' Questions like these are at the root of
hatred. They doubt the correctness of G-d's "distribution system". You
even go so far as to say that they reveal a lack of Faith!
Herein lies the connection between the sin of the spies and the
destruction of the Temple. The people became frightened by the report of
spies because they lacked faith in G-d's ability to deliver the Promised
Land in the face of mighty enemies. The people at the fall of Jerusalem
suffered from jealousy and selfishness which are rooted in a lack of faith
and are manifest in sin' at Hinam--baseless hatred. The night of
for both is the same Tisha B 'Ab!
This year, as we prepare for the fast of Tisha B'Ab we must get
into a mode of "corrective surgery". Drastic steps must be taken if we are
to heal the wounds of exile and bring the salvation and the restoration of
glory to our people. Love thy neighbor must be actively pursued. Lashon
ha-ra must be eliminated. Jealousy and selfishness must be exorcised from
our personalities. It's all a matter of FAITH! Our Rabbis teach that the
to learn how to correct our character is through the study of Torah. A
regular program of Torah study, with the intent to correct our faults can
bring perfection of our traits and with that the redemption we so sorely
May we all be successful in doing all that we must in order to bring
the geulah--our salvation--speedily in our days. Amen.