A Holy Nation?
by Rabbi Yehudah Prero
The Aruch HaShulchan in Orech Chaim, 473:2-3 asks as follows: "The Tur
writes 'that we do not make the B'racha of She'asa Nissim by the Seder
because we will say it later in the Hagada...' meaning that just as we make
the Bracha on Chanukah and Purim, its obvious that we should on Pesach as
well, but because of the fact that in the Hagada we discuss all the miracles
and wonders and then we make the Bracha of "Asher Ge'alanu" at the end of
Maggid, this is like making the Bracha of She'asa Nissim, and there is no
need for two Brachot. However, this reason is not enough, as by the Megilla,
we make the Bracha of Sheasa Nissim before reading the Megilla, and another
Bracha after the Megilla, so if we can say two there, why can't we say two
The Aruch HaShulchan first mentions an answer offered by the Maharil. The
Maharil said one only makes the Bracha of She'asa Nissim on a Mitzvah
D'rabanan, a mitzvah of Rabbinical origin, which means that we would make the
B'racha on Purim and Chanukah, but not on Pesach which is D'Oraisa -
Scriptural in origin. The Aruch HaShulchan writes that he does not understand
this answer, so he offers what he thinks is the true answer. The Rabanan, who
instituted and formulated the Brachot, only established Brachot when we are
blessing Hashem for commanding us to do THIS mitzvah, such as eating Matzo,
sitting in the Sukkah, blowing Shofar. They did not make Brachot out of the
mitzvah itself. As we are commanded in the Torah to tell about themiracles
of the night, and THIS is the mitzvah of the night, if we had a Bracha which
would in fact amount to fulfilling the same obligation (remembering and
mentioning the miracles) it would be a Bracha composed of a Mitzvah D'Oraysa.
The Rabanan did not make this type of Bracha. Only by a Mitzvah D'rabanan
could they formulate such a Bracha.
I hope the answer presented here helps clarify things.
Another question I received was based on another item in the first post,
which stated that the nation of Israel was taken out of Egypt only because
they were holy. A reader asked how we reconcile this with the famous teaching
of the Sages that the nation of Israel had sunk to the 49th level of Tum'ah,
impurity, before leaving Egypt. How can a "holy" nation be on such a low
level of impurity?
(For the answer to this one, some credit is due to R' Hayim Ganzweig.) The
Sages, Chazal, tell us that there were some things that the Jews were careful
about. For example, they did not change their clothing (which perhaps is why
the son of one reader came home from school saying that people wore tzi'tzis
in Egypt. As to the truth of that, I am not sure.). They did not change their
names. We also know that only one person in Egypt was involved in a forbidden
relationship, Arayot. As we said in the first posting that it is separation
from Arayot that creates holiness, the Jews were indeed holy. However, the
Jews did worship idols in Egypt. In fact, at the time of the splitting of the
sea, the angles pointed this fact out to Hashem, wondering why the Jews were
deserving of the treatment they were getting. It was because of the sin of
idol worship that the nation of Israel sunk so low and became so impure.
Hence, we see it is possible to be "holy" AND "impure" at the same time.
And now for some kid tips...
Shoshana Socher wrote that she attended a Seder where the hostess placed a
bowl of tiny candies on the table. The kids got to take a candy for each
question they asked.
Wotalf@aol.com, a father of five, wrote that : the child has to be made
into a participant. For the youngest kids, ask them at times if they know any
songs, such as "Who knows a song about Pharaoh and Frogs on his head?" For
elementary school kids, as they have been bombarded with material about
Pesach in school, get them going by asking them questions. The kids who are
kept in the seder will then begin to volunteer information. Challenge high
schoolers with questions and let them say what they learned as well. And
remember...adults get bored, too. Be ready with questions to ask everybody
at the Seder.
For questions, comments, and topic requests, please write to Rabbi Yehudah Prero.
VAYEITZEI AND CHANUKAH:
Straightening Out The Cause And The Effect
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5773
Hey, Looks Like Supper!
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5760
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5771
The Meaning of Miracles
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5766
Lend Me an Ear
Rabbi Raymond Beyda - 5767
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5766
Light Over Darkness
Rabbi Naphtali Hoff - 5768
The Hasmoneans Take a Stand: A History of Chanukah, Part II
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5774
Rabbi Wein - 5768
Chanukah, Chutzpah, and Coming Close to G-d
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5757
The 'Luz' Bone
Shlomo Katz - 5773
Oh Dreidel, Dreidel, Dreidel!
Rabbi Label Lam - 5768
Yosef Recognizes His Brothers
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5773
Every Little Bit Counts
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5763
Why Rachel Was Remembered
Rabbi Leib Kelman - 5757
Shlomo Katz - 5772