"Leishev baSukkah," To Sit in the Sukkah - A Halachik Discussion
Guest Contributor - Rabbi Yitzchok D. Frankel
As mentioned in other posts, during Sukkos there is a commandment to sit in
the Sukkah. Our Sages have written that sit means we should sit in the Sukkah
as we would dwell in our homes. Just as we eat in our homes, so too should we
eat in the Sukkah. However, this rough guideline is just that. There are many
laws concerning how we are to properly discharge the mitzvah (commandment) of
sitting in the Sukkah. Some of these laws unfortunately are unknown, yet
fundamental to the correct performance of the mitzvah of sitting in the
As a preface it is important to know that not saying the bracha (blessing)
before the performance of a mitzvah in no way hinders or obviates the
fulfillment of that mitzvah. That is the reason that we make the bracha on
the Lulav and Esrog (the Four Species - see vol I:47 ) with the Esrog upside
down. One can not fulfill the mitzvah of Lulav if any of the Four Species is
upside down. The species must be held in the way that they grow in order to
properly fulfill the commandment. By holding the esrog upside down before we
recite the blessing, we insure that the bracha is said first. If the mitzvah
would not be done this way it is conceivable that one might take the Lulav
and Esrog with the intention to fulfill the mitzvah and thereby lose the
opportunity to make the bracha. (A bracha generally can not be said after the
fulfillment of a mitzvah - only before.)
Another factor to be known is that when there is a question, in law, as to
the need to say a bracha (a blessing) one is not said.
The Torah requires all males over thirteen years old to leave their permanent
dwelling and take up a temporary dwelling for seven days beginning with the
fifteenth day of the Jewish month of Tishrei. In the case of Sukkah, a
biblical requirement prevents the eating of a minimum volume of certain foods
outside the Sukkah. There is unanimity concerning some items but there are
differing opinions concerning others.
The following are some of the practical rulings that result in making the
recitation of the following blessing : Baruch Ata Ad-noi El-heinu Melech
HaOlam Asher Kidishanu B'Mitzvosav V'Tzivanu Leishev baSukkah," Blessed are
you Hashem our G-d, King of the World, who has sanctified us with His
commandments and commanded us to sit in the Sukkah:
This in no way should be construed as limitations to the requirement of
eating in the sukkah. That is a totally different discussion and in very many
cases one would still be obligated to eat in the sukkah while being exempt
from the bracha. As mentioned above, the recitation of the bracha does not
affect performance of the mitzva. Rather, it is an added layer which carries
with it its own set of laws. Being that we are to live in the Sukkah while
the opportunity presents itself, any time in the Sukkah is time well spent.
While according to most authorities, drinking coffee alone would not
necessitate the recitation of the bracha on the Sukkah, it is still
worthwhile and praiseworthy to drink the coffee in the Sukkah. Many of the
great sages spent much time in the Sukkah. They ate, drank, slept, and
studied in the Sukkah. We as well want to gain the most from the Sukkah
experience, and that is why we are to spend time in the Sukkah.
- Even if one is sleeping or doing other activities in the sukkah the bracha
of "leishev baSukkah"(the blessing for sitting in the sukkah) is NOT said. It
is only said before (or during) eating. [Shulchan Aruch Ccode of Jewish Law)
- For one to be permitted to say the bracha of "leishev baSukkah" a minimum
of a kibeitza (the volume of an egg calculated by the displacement of water.
This volume equals to double that of a kizayis; the volume of an olive) must
be eaten in the sukkah. [O.Ch. 639:2]
- The bracha of "leishev baSukkah" would therefore be is said only when one
is eating a minimum of the above amount of bread.
- This bracha would be said when one is eating a minimum of the above amount
of non-bread products made from food of the five grains (wheat, barley, rye
oats, spelt) according to Aruch HaShulchan 639:27.
According to Mishnah Brura 639:13,15-16 and Kaf HaChaim 639:33 the following
applies for the five grains:
The bracha is said only if a) one establishes his meal on these items by
eating an amount three or four times the normal kibeitza b)one normally eats
a kibeitza or more of cake for breakfast (with coffee, etc.) c)on Shabbos
(Sabbath) or Yomtov (holidays) when one may eat a kibeitza or more of cake
after reciting the Kiddush on wine before the meal. (One would not make the
blessing during the Chol HaMoed [intermediate] days even though the prevalent
custom is to make the bracha.[See Aruch haShulchan above.] If one does make
the bracha on a weekday then one should sit awhile in the sukkah after eating
in order to do some other activity.)
- One does not make the bracha of "leishev baSukkah" when making Havdalah
(the blessing marking the separating of Shabbos and Yomtov from weekday) upon
conclusion of the festival days. [O.Ch. 369:2 MB.#13.]
Our desire to spend time in the Sukkah, however, maty be challenged.
Inclement weather is not particularly conducive to staying outdoors in a
dwelling with holes in the roof. We are only commanded to live in the Sukkah
as we would in our homes. Would we stay in our homes if there was water
dripping through the roof? This presents us with another issue: What do you
do if it rains on the first night (or second night, in the Diaspora) of
Sukkos (when we have a positive commandment to eat in the Sukkah)?
While it is not within the scope of this article to deal with all the
philosophical implications of rain on Sukkos, suffice it to say that our
sages have told us that it is not a sign of blessing to be forced out of the
Sukkah. (See vol. II:20 ) We pray, therefore, that this question remains in
the field of the theoretical.
To properly understand the following answer, a number of fundamental points
must be prefaced.
On the first night of Sukkos a married man or one eating with female family
members or young children should wait approximately one hour to see if the
rain will stop. If the rain continues he should go into the Sukkah; say the
Kiddush with the "Shehechiyanu" blessing, wash as one usually does before the
consumption of bread and eat at least a kizayis of bread in the rain. He
should not say the blessing of "leishev baSukkah." He may then complete his
meal in the house. After the meal, he should wait until slightly before the
Halachik midnight to see if the rain will stop. If the rain stops, he then
washes, enters the Sukkah again, says the brocho "leishev baSukkah," eats at
least a kibeitza of bread and then says Birkas haMazon.
- To say Birkas haMazon (Grace After Meals, recited after any meal at which
bread is consumed) at any time, a minimum of a kizayis (the volume of flour
equal to the volume of an olive) must be eaten within approximately four
- For one to be permitted to say the bracha of "leishev baSukkah," a minimum
of a kibeitza (the volume equals to double that of a kizayis) of bread or
cake must be eaten in the sukkah.
- The bracha of "Shehechiyanu" (Who has Renewed Us and Sustained us and
Brought us to this time, recited upon the first performance of each mitzva on
the holiday) relates also to the Sukkah; but only on the first night of
- There is disagreement as to the requirements of eating in the sukkah on
the first two nights of Sukkos if it is raining. The opinion of the Rama is
that there is a requirement to eat a minimum of a kizayis in the sukkah, even
in the rain, on the first two nights. Others are of the opinion that the
exemption of eating in the sukkah in the rain applies equally to all the days
- As we said above, the inability to make a bracha on a mitzvah does not
affect the fulfillment of that mitzvah.
- We are strict whenever we have a doubt concerning the fulfillment of a
biblical law (such as eating in the Sukkah on the first night of Sukkos).
- We do not make a bracha whenever we have a doubt concerning the
correctness of that bracha.
On the second night, if it rains, one need not wait at all and he may begin
his meal immediately in the house. Kiddush with "shehechiyanu" is made in the
house. This would even apply to a single person. At the end of the meal,
before saying the Grace After Meals, even if it is still raining, he should
eat a kizayis of bread in the Sukkah in the rain. Again, a bracha of "leishev
baSukkah" is not said. A bracha of "shehechiyanu" is not needed for the
sukkah on the second night. One may then go back into the house to say the
Grace After Meals. According to many opinons, even on the second night, one
should wait again until slightly before the Halachik midnight to see if the
rain stops. If the rain does stop then the procedure is the same as the first
night. On all other days or nights of Sukkos, if the rain is so strong in
the Sukkah that if it was raining in the house a person would be driven out
of his home to find other shelter, or if the rain is ruining his food,
preventing him from eating, he need not eat in the Sukkah. If one has already
started his meal inside, and the rain stops, he may complete his meal in the
Check out all of the posts on Elul and Rosh HaShana. Head over to
http://www.torah.org/learning/yomtov/ to access the YomTov Page.
Then click on the icon for the holiday of your choice.
For questions, comments, and topic requests, please write to Rabbi Yehudah Prero.
BESHALACH AND TU BESHVAT:
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5757
Shlomo Katz - 5772
A Time to Sing
Shlomo Katz - 5774
Thanks for the Suffering
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5756
Booty Is Risky
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5760
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5761
The Two Loaves
Shlomo Katz - 5773
The Illusion of Independence
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5759
Spiritual and Physical
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5769
Leaving Mitzrayim: It Is All For OUR Good
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5774
The Spiritual Effect of Tasting the Manna
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5772
As the Season Turns
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5767
The Gateway to Freedom
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5768
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5764
Look Not at the Vessel...
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5759
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5762