Gifts are not worth much if the recipient cannot keep them. In fact,
that is the very meaning of the word “gift,” something that is given,
something that may used in any way the recipient sees fit. If so, how do
we explain the Torah’s choice of words when describing the mitzvah of
giving tithes and gifts to the Kohein, the one who performs the priestly
duties for the community? Listen closely to the words of the Torah. “And
all that a man gives to the Kohein shall be his.” (5:10) Well, if he gives
it to the Kohein, then it is obviously his, isn’t it?
Some commentators perceive a novel insight in this verse. The
Torah, they explain, is addressing the instinctive defiant reaction of a
person who is required to give some of his hard-earned money to the
Kohein or to the poor. “Why should I give him my money? He didn’t
work for it. I did. Why shouldn’t I be allowed to keep it?” The Torah
reassures this person that he is mistaken, that the money given to the
Kohein is indeed money well spent, that it is actually the best by far of
all his diversified investments.
A person never really has his possessions firmly in his grasp. If he
uses them up, he many have derived some enjoyment from them, but
they are now forever gone. If he hoards them, he can never be assured
that they will stay with him. They may be stolen. He may suffer financial
reverses. Nothing is guaranteed.
The only way a person can safeguard his money and make sure he
always retains it is by using it in a way that will bring him eternal
reward. When he gives some of his to a beggar who cannot feed his family. He
has earned himself eternal reward. When he gives to the Kohein who
ministers to the spiritual needs of the community, he has earned himself
eternal reward. When he supports institutions of Torah, he has earned
himself eternal reward. This is what the Torah is saying. “And all that a
man gives to the Kohein shall be his.” Only when he uses his money for
a higher purpose does it become truly “his.” Only then is his investment
A great sage once visited a very wealthy man.
“They say you are very rich,” said the sage. “Is it true?”
“I’m afraid it is,” said the man. “I am one of the wealthiest men in
“Indeed?” said the sage. “Can you prove it to me?”
The man smiled. “I could take you on a tour of my properties, but
we would have to travel for days on end. I could show you my
storehouses of treasures, but you would become weary climbing from
one floor to the next. But I can show you my account books. Would you
like to see them?”
“Please,” said the sage.
The man took the sage into his back room and opened some of his
account books for him.
“I am not convinced,” said the sage. “Show me more.”
The man opened more and more account books for the sage, but
he was still unconvinced.
“I have no more account books,” the man finally said in frustration.
“What is that little book up on that shelf?” said the sage.
“That is the ledger of my charitable donations,” said the man.
“Show it to me!” said the sage.
He leafed through the little ledger and closed it with a smile on his
face. “I see that you are indeed a wealthy man,” said the sage. “Very
few people have given as much to charity as you have. You see, all
those other account books mean nothing. Tomorrow, you can be
penniless, and then what would you be worth? But the charity you gave
can never be taken from you. Your good deeds are yours forever.”
In our own lives, we often feel pressured by the communal charities
and all those worthy institutions who are always so desperately I need
of funds. And there is no end to it. If we give to them this year, we know
they will be back next year for more. But let us look at them from a
different perspective. Let us see them as an opportunity to make an
investment that will bear dividends for ourselves and our families for all
eternity, in this world and the next. Let us be thankful that we are
fortunate to be on the giving end and that by doing so we enrich our
own lives beyond measure.
Text Copyright © 2011 by Rabbi Naftali Reich and Torah.org.
Rabbi Reich is on the faculty of the Ohr Somayach Tanenbaum Education Center.