Volume 4 Issue 52
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
The song of Ha'azinu encompasses a panoramic view of Jewish history. It
tells of the past, present, and future of Klal Yisrael. However, Moshe
does not end the portion with a song. He exhorts them to take his words
seriously and apply them to their hearts. Then he reiterates the most
prevalent theme of all his teachings "be careful to perform the entire
Torah, for it is not an empty thing for you, for it is your life"
The spectrum from "not an empty thing" to "it is your life" is extremely
broad. It is quite disconcerting to see Moshe telling the nation he had
guided with the words of Torah proclaim that Torah is not an empty thing.
Can he have meant something deeper?
Rashi tells us that he in fact did mean something deeper. There is no
empty thing in Torah. Every fact and seeming minutia bear tremendous
relevance, even the seemingly trivial fact that is written in Sefer
Braishis, "the sister of Lotun was Timna," (Genesis 36:22) is a springboard
for philosophical, historical and even kabalistic discussions (see Sifri 336).
Again, something needs clarification. The Torah tells us that there is not
one thing empty, irrelevant, and trivial in the Torah, as it is your life.
Is there no middle ground? Can something be important yet not be life
When I was in seventh grade one of my classmates was frustrated at a
difficult commentary that Rashi had cited. "I don't like this Rashi,"
quipped the student.
My Rebbe, Rabbi Shmuel Dishon, stopped him short with a story that
occurred to his friend Chaim.
Chaim was on a tour of Paris' Louvre. On the tour was an elderly American
woman, whose appreciation for art must have begun and ended with her
grandchildren's works which hung proudly on her refrigerator. As the guide
passed the Mona Lisa, the oohs and ahs of the crowd were drowned out by the
cynicism of the woman.
"Is she smiling or not smiling? Can't DiVinci make up his mind?" she
kvetched. The Rembrandts and Reubens did not forego her criticisms either.
When the guide began to explain the distinction of painting style, the
differences of oils and brushstrokes and a host of other amazing facts and
analysis, the women let out a sigh of impatience. "I really don't see what
is so wonderful about these pictures! My grů" The guide cut her short. In
perfect English with a French accent, he began.
"My dear madam, when you go to the Louvre you must realize the paintings
are no longer on trial. They have already been scrutinized and analyzed by
those who have spent their entire lives studying art. Every stroke of the
brushes have been praised and critiqued. What hangs here are the standard
bearers for every generation of artists to come.
"No my dear," he continued, "at the Louvre, the paintings are not on
trial. It is you who are on trial. The paintings have passed the test.
It is you who have failed."
Needless to say, my classmate understood our Rebbe's point.
In order to appreciate every detail of the Torah and to understand that
every fact, figure, and seemingly trivial detail contain endless depth and
countless meanings, one must make the Torah his life. Moshe is telling us
more than a critique of Torah wisdom; he is teaching us a fundamental Torah
principle. "There is not one empty thing in Torah when it is your life!"
If one makes a serious career of Torah study, if he analyzes and commits
himself to Torah knowledge, he will be amazed at the never-ending lessons,
laws, and lifestyle morals he will glean from it.
Imagine, in 1637, mathematician Pierre de Format wrote a tiny theorem. On
the margin of his notebook he noted that he found a truly wondrful proof
which this margin is too small to contain.
For 350 years, in universities around the world, mathematiciens toiled
unsuccessfully to decipher the riddle. It was their life and they lived to
fit in the missing pieces of what may seem to many of us as insignificant
mathematical minutia. But to those who live math, it is not empty. For
there is nothing empty in it when it is your life.
Surely , the everlasting words of the Torah contain the theorems that
sustain us eternally. NAd they are to be found in its tiniest details. We
must, however, actively pursue it. And when you are truly in pursuit of
its truth, you will find that the Torah contains nothing trivial.
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
Dedicated by Mr. & Mrs. Josh Kalter in memory of Helen Wincelberg
Copyright © 1998 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion
which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation