COPYING ONE'S OWN CD FOR SAFEKEEPING
QUESTION 82: COPYING ONE'S OWN CD FOR SAFEKEEPING
Can I make a copy of my own CD or tape, and put it away,
in case it breaks or gets lost?
RABBI BELSKY
I think it is universally accepted that when you buy a CD,
you are allowed to make a backup copy of the CD. This way
if you break or lose the CD, you still have a copy to replace
the original, and you don't have to buy another one. I
tried to look into this, and I believe that this is the
accepted practice - that a person who buys a tape or CD can make
a backup copy of it.
The bottom line when making a copy is that there shouldn't
be two people who have the same tape or CD, when only
one paid for it. That's the easiest way to define the
central issue. If two people have use of a tape or CD at
the same time, that means both people should have paid.
If there are two users, there should have been two customers.
But if there is one user who just wants to make sure that
he doesn't lose his tape or CD, and makes a copy, then we only
have one user, with an extra backup, and that's allowed.
QUESTIONER
If it breaks, and I hadn't made a copy, can I borrow the same
title from a friend, and then make a copy for myself?
RABBI BELSKY
If it breaks and you had forgotten to make a backup, does that
mean you are now stuck, and have to go out and buy another
original version of the tape or CD? I would say that you could
act as if you had been wise and prudent in the beginning, and
could make a backup now - by making a copy from someone who
has one. The producer of the tape or CD doesn't expect there to
be two users who buy three originals. His intention is that there
are two users who buy two original copies. You're not taking away
from his business, or causing him a loss.
I think it can be done because you had the right to do this
before you lost it. You just assumed that you wouldn't
break or lose it.
NEXT WEEK'S QUESTION 83: COPYING A CD BEFORE REPLACING IT
I borrowed a CD from a friend and lost it. I'm now
going to buy the same title, in order to 'give back'
the CD to him, to replace the one I lost. Before I
give him the replacement CD, can I make a copy for
myself?
Participate in the Honesty Forum, and discuss the issues we confront in this class!
Subscribe to Honesty and receive this class via e-mail.
