Rosh Hashana/Yom Kippur
by Rabbi Yaakov Menken
We find ourselves this week in the midst of the Ten Days of Repentance,
the days from Rosh HaShana to Yom Kippur. An interesting idea - ten
days for self-examination, reflection, and (we hope) self-improvement.
But do we understand "repentance?"
The world today almost laughs at "sin" and "repentance." Almost? Let
me rephrase that: the world does laugh at the whole idea of "sin."
Part of that is denial - if I laugh at something, I don't have to take
it seriously. Another part, however, comes from the non-Jewish
conception of sin and repentance - which, because of the society we live
in, has become quite pervasive in Jewish minds.
Many who no longer go to church describe confession as "going on Sunday
to confess what we did Friday, and plan to do again on Tuesday." I
don't know if that's accurate; I'm Jewish. I only know that this could
not be further from the Jewish idea of repentance.
So instead of these terms, let us use "transgression" and "return," words
which correspond more closely to a Jewish understanding of these concepts.
Indeed, while we may translate "Teshuva" as repentance, it comes from the
infinitive LaShuv: to return.
We know certain things to be right, and others to be wrong, and we cross
the line. We go where we should not have gone - and in doing so, we
move away from G-d. But in His great kindness, He leaves the door open
for us to come back to Him, and restore our connection. That is the
purpose of return - to come back to G-d.
If so, is it not obvious that Teshuva must happen in our hearts, and
not in our mouths? Maimonides, in his codification of Jewish Law, says
this explicitely (Hil. Tshuva 2:3): "One who confesses with words, but
has not decided in his heart to abandon [his transgressions], is like a
person who goes to a ritual bath while holding something unclean in his
hand: immersion in the bath will not help him until he throws the
Repentance is an activity of the heart - a decision to change our
behavior, and to abandon a path that has led us away from G-d instead of
towards Him. And to make it easier for us, G-d gave us a certain time
of year when He comes close to us, and invites us to go in the right
direction. The Talmud in tractate Rosh HaShana says that the verse, "Seek
out HaShem when He can be found, call upon Him when He is close" (Isaiah
55:6) refers to these Ten Days. Maimonides also says (2:6) that "Even
though return and crying [over our errors] is always beautiful, during the
ten days between Rosh HaShana and Yom Kippur it is exceptionally so, and
is accepted immediately" - and he refers us again to that same verse.
It is as if G-d is right here in the neighborhood, and all we need to do
is drop in! It is that easy for us to use this time for a rebirth, for
making new beginnings in the right direction. Should we wake up in two
weeks, feeling as if He left without us? Let's take advantage of this
time of year, and come away from the season feeling closer to G-d.
Text Copyright © 1995 Rabbi Yaakov Menken and Project Genesis, Inc.
The author is the Director of Project Genesis.