by Rabbi Yaakov Menken
"And these are the judgments which you shall place before them..."
Rashi, Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki, comments that "just as the previous
commandments were given at Sinai, so too these were given at Sinai." The
commandments given in last week's parsha were between man and G-d, along
with fundamental interpersonal laws such as the prohibitions on murder and
theft. This week's commandments are more "common" laws of financial
judgments and courts.
The Chidushei HaRim explains that we might mistakenly think that because
these laws have a clear and obvious logic, and are a necessary part of any
civilization, that they are not Divine Commandments but rather human
legislation. Therefore the Torah testifies that these are from Sinai, just
like the Divine decrees whose meaning is primarily spiritual. The Chidushei
HaRim says that these judgments are also spiritual, and we should observe
them because they are Divine, not merely because society needs them.
The Kol Simcha focuses on the words "before them," explaining that each
person must place the laws before himself. Each person is responsible for
ensuring that the entire system functions, and must be totally dedicated to
As all America questions its legal system this week, it is worthwhile to
wonder if any system could function properly when the average person didn't
trust the leadership to do that which is just and correct. While the
previous "verdict" demonstrated the obvious failures of a jury composed of
"peers" rather than those with a decent legal education, a judicial system
of judges is only preferable when the judges are trusted to be moral and
upright - and today the average American hardly regards lawyers with this
level of respect.
A system of human origin only works when people trust the humans who run it
- and today, many people believe that the American system is not worthy of
that trust. So it collapses, as each person or community looks out for its
own interests rather than the justice system overall. The Jewish system
forces each individual to demonstrate an active concern for that which is
right and just, and to seek out judges who demonstrate only the best
conduct. We do it not for society's sake - and certainly we do not look
only towards our own interests. Rather, we as individuals must build a
system which fulfills our responsibilities to the Divine.
Text Copyright © 1997 Rabbi Yaakov Menken and Project Genesis,
The author is the Director of Project Genesis.
About the Author