By Rabbi Yisroel Ciner
This weeks parsha, Bechukosai, is the final parsha in Sefer Vayikra. "Im bechukosai telechu..."- if, with my commandments
you will walk... "I will send your rains in their time" (26:3). Rashi explains that these 'commandments' refers to our toiling in
What is meant by this "walking"? I'll take the liberty of choosing from the 42 different explanations that the Ohr HaChaim
offers. The pursuit of Torah differs greatly from that of individual mitzvos. Whereas a sin can 'extinguish' a mitzvah, it can never
extinguish the merit of one’s Torah. If one toils in Torah, he is guaranteed that it will walk with him- it will accompany him to
the next world.
Another explanation he brings is that man, unlike the animal kingdom, has the ability to change himself and improve. Our pasuk
comes to reveal to us what gives man this ability to move, to change, to improve. If you will toil in Torah then you will walk!
That is the only way for a true sustained improvement.
I'm often haunted by a quote I saw at the Yad V'shem Holocaust Museum. One of the Nazi arch killers (yimach shmom
v'zichrom) commented that it's quite an accomplishment to be involved in mass murder while at work and still manage to be a
good fellow amongst one’s friends. The only way to truly improve and change oneself, to truly 'be a good fellow', is thorough
the toil of Torah.
Another explanation is given by the R' Nachum Zev, the son of the Saba of Kelm. Often, when a group of friends are together
in Yeshiva, it is very hard to discern a difference between them. When do their true strengths become apparent? Upon their
leaving the Yeshiva. When each goes his separate path, when their true aspirations become realized, then tremendous
differences are seen between them.
If, with my commandments, you will walk! What will you take with you? How will you behave when you are on your own?
What lasting effect will the Yeshiva and your learning have on you? If, with my commandments, you will walk! That is the true
We have a basic concept of 'schar mitzvos b'hai alma lekah', there is no reward for mitzvos in this world. The only place
that there can be a proper accounting for ones spiritual acts is in the spiritual realm.
A story is told of some students of the Chofetz Chaim who approached their Rebbe. They were very poor and had come to
offer a desperate solution. "We are willing to forego on a small amount of the reward for our mitzvos in the next world. Let
Hashem give some reward in this world to alleviate our difficult predicament."
The Chafetz Chaim answered with a parable. When one is buying an $8 item, it would be expected to get change from a $10
bill. For a $7 item, one could break a $20. To give a $50 bill to pay for a $5 item would raise an eyebrow. A $100 bill for a
$3 item would probably be refused. Imagine trying to use a $10,000,000 check to pay for a piece of gum. Impossible! You
simply can't break such a large denomination for such a small purchase.
The eternal reward for a mitzvah, an act of connection between man and Hashem, is so colossal that it can't be 'broken' to pay
off inconsequential, trivial money in this world. It is because of the huge reward awaiting them that they can't be paid in part in
This brings us to a question from our parsha. "If you will keep the commandments... I will give the rain in your land." Isn't this a
pledge of reward in this world? Haven't we established that as not being payable!
The Rambam explains that our parsha, and other similar parshas in the Torah, are not speaking of reward. This world is the
arena that affords us the opportunity to draw close to Hashem through the mitzvos. If a person will keep the commandments,
then Hashem will create an environment that is conducive to the continued fulfillment of such mitzvos. Not reward but rather
the logical outcome of the acts.
This brings us to an understanding of the tochacha- the harsh and chilling punishments that will result from our not fulfilling our
obligations. "V'im lo tishm'u li... (25:14)" - and if you won't listen to me... then we klal Yisroel will go through tremendous
hardship until we'll rectify our attitudes and actions.
This tochacha is in fact an act of tremendous kindness from Hashem. Let's try to gain an understanding in this and, in general,
the hardships that Hashem sends our way.
Rav Shimshon Raphael Hirsch offers a fascinating insight into Adom Harishon being chased out of the Garden of Eden. Before
the sin, when he had a pure and unsullied connection to Hashem, Gan Eden was the perfect environment for him to be in.
However, after being pulled to the physical, after integrating evil as a part of himself, he needed to be removed from those
surroundings. He needed to be in an environment where the pleasures were not as easily accessible. An environment where
"with the sweat of his brow he would eat bread". That now became the perfect environment for him. That now became his Gan
Eden. The perfect environment for us changes as we change.
Imagine a parent who watches his child walking along the edge of a cliff and decides not to shout a warning out of fear of
upsetting the child. Ridiculous! Irresponsible! Call Social Services immediately!
Imagine a student who doesn't use the abilities that he has and just 'goes through the motions' during the years of his education.
Teachers see his potential, recognize the waste and do nothing. Again, irresponsible! Cruel! A breach of their obligation!
A shout is the kindest possible act. An approving glance- the cruelest possible reaction.
If we recognize this when it comes to this transient world, how much more so when we are dealing with eternity. If Hashem
sees a person acting in a way that he'll regret for a long time afterwards, the obvious and kindest reaction is to jolt that person
out of his state of apathy and ignorance. He'll need a new environment where things, perhaps, won't be as easy. Where some
pain and hardship will force him to reevaluate his priorities and view life differently. That will become his Gan Eden - the best
possible environment for his growth.
The lesson that we need to learn from the tochacha is that kindness can be, at times, the greatest cruelty and cruelty can, at
times, be the greatest kindness.
May we merit to toil in Hashem's Torah, putting ourselves in a state of constant movement toward Him. Seeing the tov in all
that comes our way, recognizing that our personal situation is our personal Gan Eden, and making ourselves worthy recipients
of His blessing.
Copyright © 1997 by Rabbi Yisroel Ciner
and Project Genesis, Inc.
The author teaches at Neveh Zion in
Telzstone (near Yerushalayim).