We left Avigail, at the end of our previous class, preparing her appeal to
David, in order to avert his imminent attack on her husband and their
household. This class examines the details of Avigail's appeal, and follows
the events that culminate in her marriage to David. In Avigail's
interaction with the two diametrically opposing personalities of David and
Naval we see the breadth and versatility of her truly righteous character.
Avigail's Righteous Conduct Within a Bad Relationship:
a Message for Today
Avigail intercedes with David, as an advocate for both herself and her
undeserving husband. She moves forward programmatically - with wisdom,
confidence and depth - addressing a complex of issues each as separate
entity and as part of an integrated, problematic whole. Avigail first
responds to David's initial request for food. This demonstrates her desire
to correct her husband's wrongdoing immediately, before she addresses the
other aspects of his transgression. Avigail is disturbed by the fact that
she was not present when David's men had asked Naval for provisions.
The amount of food that Avigail presents to David upon their encounter is
evidence of her enormous generosity and her commitment to replace
wrongdoing with righteousness:
"... Avigail hurried and took two hundred breads, two containers of wine,
five cooked sheep, five se'ahs of toasted grain, a hundred raisin clusters,
and two hundred cakes of pressed figs, and she put them on the donkeys..."
(I Samuel 25:18).
That Avigail is able to immediately assemble such a gift suggests the
abundance she maintains in her home for her husband. In other words,
regardless of her husband's baseness, Avigail holds herself to the highest
standards of conduct. She behaves righteously for her own sake and not
just for Naval's.
As she presents her gift to David, Avigail asks that he blame her and not
her husband for the earlier affront. Avigail argues effectively - and
truthfully - that since Naval's inhospitable attitude is a part of his poor
character, David should not have expected anything more than the response
he received. Avigail claims that David's men came because they knew of her
own renowned generosity and, in this regard, it is she who fell short:
"With me myself, my lord, lies the sin...Let my lord not set his heart
against this base man - against Naval - for he is as his name implies -
Naval is his name and revulsion is his trait; and I, your maidservant, did
not see my lord's attendants whom you sent...And now, this homage that your
maidservant has brought to my lord - let it be given to the attendants who
are traveling with my lord" (I Samuel 25:23- 27).
With David's acceptance of her gift, Avigail moves on to resolve a more
difficult set of issues. According to Torah, her husband is to incur the
death penalty for having spoken disrespectfully towards and for questioning
the royal lineage of David, who has been annointed the next king. Avigail
urges David to reverse this mandate, pointing out to him that he is not
officially the practicing king, because his predecessor, Shaul, still
occupies the throne. For this reason, she concludes, the decision to kill
Naval may not yet be within David's jurisdiction. Consequently he risks
serious wrongdoing, and would best at this time leave Naval's fate to God:
"And may it be that when Hashem performs for my lord all the beneficence of
which he has spoken regarding you, and appoints you as leader over Israel,
that this not be for you a stumbling block and a moral hindrance for my
lord to have shed innocent blood for my lord to have avenged himself" (I Samuel 25: 27-31).
David subsequently agrees not to attack Naval, and expresses his gratitude
to Avigail for having prevented him from taking Naval's fate into his own
hands. Avigail returns home, having saved her husband's life - and her own
- to find Naval still celebrating his sheep-shearing. In spite of her
important news Avigail waits until morning to speak with her husband, so as
not to interrupt his party. In her choice, we see again Avigail's
fixed commitment to doing the right thing, regardless of whether or not her
husband deserves her courtesy.
As explained in our previous class, since the Torah does not examine
Avigail's reasons for remaining with Naval, one may assume they are not a
part of what the prophet Samuel intends to convey in this story. From a
contemporary point of view, the fact that Avigail stays in her marriage
might entitle her to treat her husband poorly, as compensation for
tolerating him. To the contrary, Avigail seems aware that leaving Naval
remains a viable option and she does not blame him for her decision not to
leave. She discharges her domestic responsibilities as Naval's wife in the
same way she would have, had she been married to a good man.
Naval dies soon after Avigail's meeting with David, and she subsequently
becomes David's wife.
As Jews, we have inherited Avigail's dedication to doing the right thing
regardless of circumstances, and we may use this gift as a guide for
self-improvement within our relationships. We have the right to leave a
relationship - whether marriage, friendship or professional. However, if
we stay, we must commit to treat the "other" with respect, unless we need
to resort to disrespect for self-protection. (Self-protection against
David's onslaught, is Avigail's reason for speaking poorly about her
husband to David. She mentions Naval's inherently bad character only
because it is a part of her effort to save herself and her husband).
Why does Avigail maintain her own righteousness, when her husband is so
inferior - and why is it worthwhile for us to follow Avigail's
example? Simply stated, our own poor behavior has a detrimental effect on
us and derails our efforts to become better people. For today's Jewish
woman in any relationship Avigail teaches that in most cases improper
conduct is a bankrupt approach. Admittedly, the Torah sets forth in Avigail
and Naval an extreme case of good married to bad which, on a practical
level, might be impossible to endure. Nonetheless, we may apply Avigail's
approach towards our own self-improvement within the context of our
relationships and, in so doing, perfect ourselves to the greatest extent.
Women in Judaism, Copyright (c) 2002 by Mrs. Leah Kohn and Project Genesis, Inc.
TZAV AND PURIM:
A Major Player
Rabbi Label Lam - 5765
The Face We Show
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5762
You Can Do It!
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5766
Perspectives on Trouble
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5758
Shlomo Katz - 5773
Our Whole Selves
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5764
Greatest Accolade Given To Mordechai
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5757
No Free Meal
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5771
His Worst Nightmare Realized
Rabbi Label Lam - 5768
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5760
One Time, or Always?
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5760
Troubles Aren't Just a Good Reason to Pray
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5758
Celebrate With Your Whole Self
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5758
No Free Meal
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5773
Teshuva from Love
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5773
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5770