Support Torah.org

Subscribe to a Torah.org Weekly Series

Posted on September 5, 2025 (5785) By Rabbi Yaakov Menken | Series: | Level:

“You may not look upon your brother’s donkey or ox fallen in the roadway, and turn your eyes away from them; rather, you shall surely lift them up with him.” [22:4]

We are obligated to help another person struggling to get his animal back on its feet, with the burden it is carrying.

The Medrash points out, however, that the verse only obligates us to help—not replace—the owner. One could imagine a lazy slacker walking away, saying “since you have the Mitzvah to load my animal, do your Mitzvah!” The Medrash tells us that we have no obligation in that case; the verse says “with him,” excluding someone who fails to work on his own behalf.

Something quite similar is debated today: whether an able-bodied individual can refuse to work but still demand government benefits. Even with an animal struggling under a load, the Torah says that communal help can only be expected when the owner is willing to do his share.

The Chofetz Chaim, Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan, says that this same principle applies to spiritual matters. We need to make an effort, and only then can we expect that G-d will step in to help us.

If a person says “guard my tongue from evil” when concluding his prayers, and then makes an effort to refrain from gossip and other evil speech, Heaven will assist him—he will find that people stop coming to him with their gossip, trying to tempt him. But if a person merely pays lip service (excuse the pun) to the concept while making no attempt to improve his own behavior, how can he request Divine Intervention? He first needs to try to uplift himself, and then G-d will help him to rise.

Similarly, our morning prayers read, “open our eyes [to understand] your Torah.” If we don’t sit down to study, then how can this prayer be realized?

The Chofetz Chaim offers the following parable: imagine someone asking a friend for a loan. The second man agrees, and asks the borrower to please come to him at home to receive the money he needs. If the borrower is lazy and never goes to the lender’s house, can he be upset at the lender’s failure to fulfill his pledge?

Similarly, we ask G-d to help us to grow and to come closer to Him. We ask him for Torah knowledge. G-d listens! And He answers, “your request is good. Now take out a book, and I will enlighten you.” If we run out the door instead, and never bother to sit down to learn, what should we expect?

The Talmud says [Tractate Makkos 10b], “in the path that a person wants to go, they guide him.” We first need to demonstrate that we want to go in that direction!