Moshe's Last Stand
Volume 3 Issue 43
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
This week the most illustrious career in Biblical history begins its final
chapters. Moshe is officially informed that he will pass on and is told who
his successor would be. But in informing Moshe of the transition, Hashem
repeats both here in the Book of Bamidbar (27:12) and again in the Book of
Devorim (32:51) the reason that Moshe will not lead the B'nai Yisrael into
the Land of Israel. It is because he hit the water producing rock instead
of speaking to it.
Why does Hashem seem to stress Moshe's sin? Rashi, the classic medieval
commentator, explains that Moshe asked Hashem to publicly declare his sin in
order to declare that this sin was his only flaw. He was afraid lest some
would say that he, too, was amongst those who were destroyed for rebellion
in the desert. He was afraid that he would be equated with the rebels and
sinners. Thus, he asked Hashem to emphasize that the only flaw he committed
was that of the rock.
It is very difficult to understand. How could Moshe even suspect that
anyone would place him on that level? How could one even imagine that he
was excluded from entering Israel for an act of treason that led to the
demise of others? Why was it so important to Moshe that the Torah
reiterates that the incident at the rock was his only transgression?
Radio commentator Paul Harvey once presented a piece of American history in
the following manner:
George Armstrong was appointed to the United States Military Academy in
1857. After graduating and commissioned in the cavalry, he quickly
established a reputation for daring and brilliance in battle. His
reputation was so well acclaimed that at the age of twenty-three, he was
made the youngest brigadier general in United States history. George's
energy and cunning paralleled the other great Georges who left their mark on
military history -- Generals George Washington and George S. Patton. In
fact, George Armstrong was so successful, that by the end of the Civil War
he became of the one of the most celebrated commanders.
His pursuit of Lee's army from Richmond in April 1865 destroyed the
confederate lines of defense and captured prisoners, wagons, and guns -
until, on the morning of April 9 he had totally defeated the enemy. It was
to no one other than General George Armstrong that the Confederate flag of
defeat was first presented.
After the Civil War, his career continued to flourish. He was assigned to
the newly formed seventh Cavalry, Fort Riley, Kansas, and was promoted to
the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. In the fall of 1868 he won a brilliant
victory over Black Kettle's band of Cheyenne Indians in the battle of the
Washita and took part in many successful engagements over the next eight
But history has almost no recollection of the illustrious career of General
George Armstrong. On June 22, 1876, General George Armstrong and his
regiment, a force of about 655 men, set out for Little Bighorn. He
encountered an overwhelming force of at least 4,000 well-armed Sioux
warriors and was killed together with his entire regiment.
No longer were the Civil War successes the hallmark of General George
Armstrong's career. Only remembered is the great defeat at Little Bighorn
led by General George Armstrong - did I mention his last name -- Custer -
General George Armstrong Custer at his last stand.
People often tend to forget the illustrious careers of great people because
of a flaw that ended it. Moshe was punished for an infraction that is
difficult to comprehend in mortal terms. He hit a rock, and produced water
-- one of history's greatest miracles -- for a thirsting nation. Yet
something was wrong. He was supposed to speak to the rock and instead he
hit it. And between him and his Creator, there was a price to pay. We
however must realize that a mistake, as great as its consequences were,
cannot mar the illustrious career of the man who led us out of Egypt and
developed us into the nation that we are today. In no way can that
punishment diminish any regard that we have for Moshe. At Moshe's
departure, that point was to be reiterated repeatedly. It is only because
of the rock that he did not enter.
How often does a man who works tirelessly for years and who errs in his last
stand, go down in disgrace for the act that terminated his career? How many
people's last stand becomes their most notorious if not their only stand?
Perhaps Hashem's reiteration vis-a-vis Moshe are a lesson to all of us.
There are no first stands and there are no last stands. If we stand for
something worthy, then we stand forever!
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!